3 ms·
The Japanese surrendered before the nukes. The US claimed the message was lost in transit. A decade or so ago, the relevant stuff was declassified. We got th
by hedora 5y ago
The Japanese surrendered before the nukes. The US claimed the message was lost in transit.
A decade or so ago, the relevant stuff was declassified. We got the message. The president decided to go forward with the nukes anyway. We had approximately 1.5 bombs, without more on the way, so it was a massive bluff. Knowing Japan would fold immediately after the bombings was a huge advantage.
Edit: the communications I'm referring to were via closed diplomatic channels. The public surrender announcement and face saving came later.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoThat is not true by any history I've read about it, and I've read a lot. It would been widely known. It's a conspiracy. Do you have proof of this or just some hearsay from "a high level source" ? Lots of people claim this stuff but never present solid evidence or documents that are verifiable.
- hedora 5y agoDuring one of the recent declassifications, '05? '15?, reputable national US news networks said the new documents proved the US knew Japan was attempting to surrender before the bomb was dropped. This page is at an .edu, and is more ambiguous on the issue, saying it is an open question, and as of 2020 still being debated. It seems to link to databases of primary sources: https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/briefing-book/nuclear-vault/2020-08-04/atomic-bomb-end-world-war-ii https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/briefing-book/nuclear-vault/2020-0...
- ncmncm 5y agoThis very interesting! Pointing to a reliable source would be most welcome. The overwhelming majority of things that happened are not widely known. That is necessarily how reality is.