3 ms·
I wonder why new planes are so complex. Computers make it technologically feasible to simplify things, but also to make them more complicated. Big organizatio
by hedora 5y ago
I wonder why new planes are so complex.
Computers make it technologically feasible to simplify things, but also to make them more complicated. Big organizations always inject as much complexity as possible into engineering projects.
- 6581 5y ago> I wonder why new planes are so complex. They're not. Older planes required more personnel (flight engineers, navigators, etc.). Newer planes are vastly easier to operate with just a captain and first officer.
- kcplate 5y agoBack about 20 years ago a buddy was showing me his new airplane. Damn avionics ran on Windows NT. I told him he’d never ever get me up on that thing.
- sammalloy 5y agoSome info about that product here, starting on page 7: https://www.faa.gov/aircraft/air_cert/design_approvals/air_software/media/AR-01-26_COTS.pdf https://www.faa.gov/aircraft/air_cert/design_approvals/air_s... Here’s the funny part at the end: > The manufacturer admitted that desktop products in general are not good candidates for avionics, and the COTS components that are most likely to be effective are industrial-grade components with a wide distribution base such as medical-based products.
- kcplate 5y agoThats awesome. What’s ironic—I think he thought I’d be impressed…and that I would be more likely to want to fly in it. However at the time I was working as a Network Engineer (for him) and I while I was happy to entrust my livelihood to Microsoft, I would definitely not trust my life to Microsoft
- 2143 5y ago> Damn avionics ran on Windows NT OMG. I thought for things where human lives are acutely at stake they audit every single line of code. I mean, Windows has a known history of crashes and freezes and things like that. I'd trust some kind of unix (BSD) a lot more than NT. Tangential: For many non-consumer applications, I see plenty of situations where you'd think a Unix variant (or even bare metal electronics) would be an obvious choice, but no it's usually a software running on top of Windows. Like, my local tyre shop has their wheel alignment software running on Windows XP. Before seeing that, I'd have thought it'd be some contraption with sensors attached to 7-segment LED display or something, which would also theoretically be able to run forever.
- kcplate 5y agoYeah, I wasn’t too keen on the notion of being a couple thousand feet in the air watching the pilot having to bounce their avionics software. Or…asking me to troubleshoot the damn thing since I had a Windows NT MCP at that time.
- 2143 5y ago"Is there a software engineer on board?" (similar to "is there a doctor on board?")
- Zak 5y agoBroadly speaking, because they have to be able to handle a huge range of conditions. A Cessna 152 (a single-engine, two-seat, low-performance aircraft popular for flight training) isn't very complex to operate. It can't fly at 30,000 feet, cross continents in a single flight, fly in icing conditions, land in zero visibility, safely take off or land in a crosswind that could be described as more than a stiff breeze, or carry much more than two people and a backpack. Airliners do all of those things. Military aircraft have similar performance demands, and people shooting at them. Automation can probably simplify everyday operation more than it has so far, but virtually every system that can be put on an aircraft has failed in flight at some point so pilots have to be able to quickly identify malfunctions and manually override a half-working system. For a recent example of what happens when that isn't the case, see the 737 Max.
- hedora 5y agoOK, but older airliners and military vessels also met those demands and were much simpler than modern airliners.
- roeles 5y agoInterestingly, the F-22 appears to handle stuff like engine failures for you[1]. Perhaps it's inertia of regulations and training. Radically automating airplanes involves training loads of people. There's also certification, which is different for military aircraft than for civilian aircraft. [1] https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=n068fel-W9I https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=n068fel-W9I