4 ms·
The older I get, the more I believe the issue is with centralization (which the DMCA had a huge part in establishing). What if there were no redit servers, and
by hedora 5y ago
The older I get, the more I believe the issue is with centralization (which the DMCA had a huge part in establishing).
What if there were no redit servers, and each subredit was self hosted? What would the incentive be for people to post child porn on some small independently run server?
As the subredit owner, you could just censor whoever you wanted, with very little global internet drama. Tools for autoflagging posts could still exist. Over-censored forums would piss off users, and be easily replaced. Similarly, under censored ones would lose users / get busted.
This all worked fine pre-internet. Editors would decide who and what would be posted.
It still works for things like audio fiction podcasts, where "slush readers" filter submissions, and money / reputation are exchanged when stuff gets published. In addition to leading to much better moderation than the big Internet sites, it creates jobs for domain experts.
The main problem is that it doesn't scale to a $1B/mo business that investors can siphon money off of. Instead, it's best structured as an ecosystem of small botique businesses.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> What would the incentive be for people to post child porn on some small independently run server? But... that's precisely what the article is about? > The Korean agent showing Janczewski around eventually pointed the phone’s camera at a desktop computer on the floor of Son’s bedroom, a cheap-looking tower-style PC with its case open on one side. The computer’s guts revealed the hard drives that Son seemed to have added, one by one, as each drive had filled up with terabytes of child exploitation videos. > This was the Welcome to Video server. > "I was expecting some kind of glowing, ominous thing," Janczewski remembers, "and it was just this dumpy computer. It was just so strange. This dumpy computer, that had caused so much havoc around the world, was sitting on this kid’s floor."
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoUsenet was rife with such content. Decentralization is not a solution to moderation.
- werber 5y agoyeah, I mean, I don't know what the solution is, like I am looking, but, I have no damn idea.
- strken 5y agoPeople don't need an incentive to upload disgusting or illegal content. They do it all the time just to annoy others. I built and ran a very small web app as a joke for a party, where friends could upload pictures of themselves drinking a beer. When I remembered it existed and went to take it down a year later, someone had registered an account and uploaded about a hundred megabytes of gore: images of dead or injured people. Other friends have had the same problem with actual child pornography.
- Manuel_D 5y agoDoes the centralization make the situation worse? I agree that there's probably a larger total number of illegal materials shared on large sites, because they get the most traffic. I'm less convinced that that the same amount of user activity fragmented across a hundred different companies would see more effective enforcement. Remember, stats about how over 90% of CSE material reports to law enforcement come from Facebook is testament to how effective the reporting infrastructure is. I've also read articles about how Bing and Duck Duck Go are not as effective at filtering abuse material than Google - which is not an dig against the former, but an byproduct of lower available resources. I don't think decentralization would improve that.
- shadowgovt 5y agoThe centralization is a two-sided coin. It provides a larger target where failure of the system to regulate content can impact more users. But it also provides economies of scale in the regulation apparatus having outsized impact when it is improved. The tricky question is whether the mute grows proportional to the megaphone.
- nl 5y ago> the more I believe the issue is with centralization > This all worked fine pre-internet. Editors would decide who and what would be posted. Obviously this argument is inconsistent. It's also wrong. The worst problem isn't with Reddit, it's with sites like the one reported in the article. These are exactly like the "under censored ones [sites]" you advocate for above. They don't lose users - they gain the types of users who want that kind of material.