Because then all your edits have to go directly into the file, so you have no real "save" flow unless you make a swap file for every file and then mmap that (wh

Because then all your edits have to go directly into the file, so you have no real "save" flow unless you make a swap file for every file and then mmap that (which can be an appropriate approach, to a degree). Then all your caching and memory use subject to OS I/O and filesystem concerns, and you can't optimize for specific use. And inserting or deleting the middle of the file means shifting all the bytes after it. I could think of a reasonable implementation for Linux that would use mmap and fallocate, but it wouldn't "just" be an mmap, as the swap file would still need to represent a rope or a gap buffer or something else of the sort for efficient editing.