5 ms·
Calling the demand "induced" seems a little strange. Did creating the iPhone induce demand for iPhones that otherwise would not have been there? Was there pent
by robertlagrant 5y ago
Calling the demand "induced" seems a little strange.
Did creating the iPhone induce demand for iPhones that otherwise would not have been there? Was there pent up demand for iPhones that was sated by their creation?
Or did people like the utility of iPhones, and buy them in spades?
In the same way, it seems strange to term things induced/pent up demand. Increased road capacity means people could plan more car trips without worrying about sitting in traffic.
- malermeister 5y agoIncreased road capacity means more people plan car trips and end up setting in traffic :-) Traffic is people, if you increase road capacity, you'll just have more people taking the road until it's full enough for everyone to be stuck again.
- oneoff786 5y agoThe creation of a new good isn’t really an example of this effect. This is discussing systems that are basically stable, then new supply causes a higher quantity demanded. iPhones aren’t really supply limited. The traffic example is salient.
- a4isms 5y ago> Increased road capacity means people could plan more car trips without worrying about sitting in traffic. You've got it in one. People think that the biggest highway with the most lanes will mean less sitting in traffic, so they plan their trips to include it. People think that a satellite city connected to the big city with a big highway will have a short car commute, so they choose to live there. This kind of thinking induces demand until the experience of sitting in traffic for an hour on one of the widest highways in the world—like Ontario's 401—discourages people from taking the highway. So politicians spend billions widening the highway some more. Lather, rinse, repeat.
- jjoonathan 5y agoRight, but this usually turns into the argument that we shouldn't add new capacity because then it would be used, and that's such a staggeringly stupid argument that I cannot comprehend the confusion of ideas that would lead someone to embrace it. What's worse, I hear this awful argument deployed under the flag of a cause I believe in: more public transport, less roads. Guess what? If we deploy more public transport, I bet people will use it more, too! Does that mean we shouldn't? Ugh. It's so dumb it almost feels like it has to be a false flag, but I've heard it from people who I know believe what they say, so I think it's just a meme at this point. A pejorative that people throw at cars without thinking about what they are saying. "Cars are bad at scaling throughput" is the argument we need. Not this "induced demand" garbage.
- a4isms 5y ago"but this usually turns into..." You're arguing with someone who isn't present. If and when someone makes that argument here, you can refute the argument they actually make, rather than the one in your own head. Until then, you're actually arguing with your own personal straw-man. Also, and this is an actual thing in the HN guidelines, when you do argue, calling ideas staggeringly stupid and so forth is strongly discouraged.
- jjoonathan 5y agoYou're just declining to engage because you know I'm right :) Fair enough.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- a4isms 5y agoAgain, you're making things up. I never said that, I didn't even say you were wrong. I actually said you were not even wrong, and I'll say it again here: When you decide for yourself what somebody else might say—but hasn't said, or decide for yourself why you think somebody didn't say something, you're arguing with yourself. "Not even wrong" has a very specific meaning here, it means arguing from speculative premises that cannot be falsified. Like, "But other people will argue X," or, "You declined to engage because Y." Both of these statement forms are not even wrong. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong
- throwaway22032 5y agoBut you can turn this around and look at the large scale problem. Let's say that 500K people can successfully make a mid-length car journey in London per day. Number pulled out of a hat. You widen all of the roads where it's viable. Now 700K people can successfully make a mid-length car journey. Sure, I'm still stuck in traffic, I can't go further, it's no more "convenient", but it literally improves the situation. By the same token, it makes no difference to me whether 200K new homes are built in the capital - they'll probably all get filled up and I'll end up paying the same or close to. Hell I have a mortgage anyway. But that's another 200K people that can live in the place they want to.
- malermeister 5y agoOr you could build high-speed rail instead and move those 700k people faster without anyone being stuck in traffic.
- throwaway22032 5y agoSure, except they're not going to places that the rail will go. We use trains, there are lots of them, they solve different problems.
- malermeister 5y agoBuild trams, subways and local rail then. There shouldn't be places where the rail doesn't go. I live in a small village of 800 people and we have a rail connection. Remoteness is not an excuse.
- esyir 5y agoThe catch is that by rail, a trip can take 40min to an hour. By car it's less than half of that.
- malermeister 5y agoA car in the US reaches around 100km/h in the best case. Rail reaches thrice that. Not sure what kind of math you did there.
- simonh 5y ago> Was there pent up demand for iPhones that was sated by their creation? Yes, correct. That’s spot on. A lot of people were crying out for a powerful, capable, usable mobile computer to access email, the web and use applications on the go. The mobile networks had invested billions building network capacity to meet these needs. This is why there were huge queues for the very first iPhone before hardly anyone had even touched one. The mobile industry had been full of speculation about what devices we would use on these networks, how they might work and what they would look like. Before the iPhone was even announced I could tell you very clearly what I needed a mobile device to be able to do for me, but not how it would do it. Apple figured that bit out. Think about it this way. If latent demand didn’t exist, how could Apple have figured out what device to design? How could they select the features and capabilities and prioritise them? They had to target a market, even though that market didn’t exist yet. Without thinking about latent demand that sort of novel product development would be just random feature selection and then see what gets traction. For sure some companies do that, but not all. Some of them think it through and target a market they hypothesise exists.
- robertlagrant 5y agoWell, it didn't have applications when it came out. You're retrofitting history with your argument, instead of keeping your argument to history. The iPhone was terrible at everything when it came out except capacitive touch and coolness. That's fine, but let's not pretend otherwise. Terming "people wanting to buy something better/cool" as latent demand is silly. It's a new/cool thing. There's no need to pretend there's anything latent about it. Make new shiny; people buy new shiny. And that's just for Apple. Most products require massive amounts of marketing to explain to people why they should be bought. That wouldn't be needed in a world with latent demand, just waiting to be fulfilled.
- throw0101a 5y ago> Did creating the iPhone induce demand for iPhones that otherwise would not have been there? Was there pent up demand for iPhones that was sated by their creation? Invention is the mother of necessity. — Marshal McLuhan > In the same way, it seems strange to term things induced/pent up demand. Increased road capacity means people could plan more car trips without worrying about sitting in traffic. Until that new capacity is filled up and now you have even more people sitting in traffic. The only way to reduce traffic is to get people out of cars, otherwise you're just spending money to kick the can down the road. See "What People Get Wrong About Induced Demand" by the Oh The Urbanity! channel: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8wlld3Z9wRc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8wlld3Z9wRc Also "Does Induced Demand Apply to Housing?": * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c7FB_xI-U6w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c7FB_xI-U6w
- TheCoelacanth 5y agoIf you gave away iPhones for less than the cost of producing them, like we do with roads, then yes, that would induce demand for iPhones.
- robertlagrant 5y agoThat isn't the scenario. Also it's not true; people don't buy things they don't want, even if they're below cost, unless they want to sell them for more. That's not wanting the product; just the profit.
- Bancakes 5y agoAll the technology iPhones provided already existed. People just fell for the marketing