5 ms·
In general, computers just aren't that bad. Yes, it's wasteful, but... even pegging a CPU core for a few hours just doesn't use that much electricity. If you dr
by yjftsjthsd-h 5y ago
In general, computers just aren't that bad. Yes, it's wasteful, but... even pegging a CPU core for a few hours just doesn't use that much electricity. If you drove a car into the office and then turned off every computer in the building and drove home for the weekend, the commute burned more energy than you saved. I used to play with my laptops trying to get power use down, but eventually realized that I could turn off a light or lower the heat 1 degree and save at least as much power.
> SaaS is a bottomless hole where you throw your processing without thought of power consumption, just write a check and make it go away.
On the contrary, this is the best case - energy is priced in, you pay by the CPU-second, all the incentives are perfectly aligned. That it's so cheap probably demonstrates that it just isn't that big a deal (we can argue about effective subsidies, but at least Google is using enough renewable power that I doubt it).
- epgui 5y agoYou could say the same about individual cars (they don't use that much energy/hydrocarbons/electricity), but in aggregate, just like cars, compute is extremely expensive in terms of energy. Edit: note that I'm not trying to compare an individual car to an individual computer, or even aggregate cars to aggregate computers... My point was merely that aggregate compute is very energy intensive. :)
- agumonkey 5y ago90hp (an average car I believe) is 70kW, that's 1000 gaming rigs (700W) in max consumption, but I assume it would still be 1000 more under small loads. And laptops / smartphones are much lower 60/120W I think.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y ago> And laptops / smartphones are much lower 60/120W I think. Mine were actually closer to 30W, even under load (realizing this is when I stopped caring:]). EDIT: This does seem to vary a lot by device, though; I may just happen to have owned really low-power devices.
- agumonkey 5y agoYeah I know that's why I quoted larger numbers for safety, some atom laptops were 15W max I believe, I remember thinkpad X using around 25W on average. Some beefy laptops might go above 150W, some use external gpus. But on average 100W seems the ballpark. And smartphones are even lower.. the energy requirement of advanced computing are ridiculously low. Apple did help a lot here: > 2021 — Anandtech found in its analysis that power consumption for the Mac mini M1 averaged 26.5 watts at the wall, assuming a multi-threaded workload. Wifi is choppy I can't dig about iphone power usage but well, it's surely below.
- epgui 5y agoAs I tried to clarify in the edit (which preceded your comment), my point was merely that in the aggregate, compute is very energy intensive. Just for a ballpark sense of scale: > "Computers, data centers and networks consume 10% of the world’s electricity." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IT_energy_management https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IT_energy_management
- agumonkey 5y agoYeah I understood, I just thought that even planet wide, it would require each car owner to have 1000 computers to sum to the same kind of figure. I'm also saying this because some people in the energy / climate change sector said that computing electronics were insignificant (the usual suspects being heating, transportation etc)
- jstarfish 5y ago> I used to play with my laptops trying to get power use down, but eventually realized that I could turn off a light or lower the heat 1 degree and save at least as much power. You're ignoring the practical benefits of engineering power-efficient software for the mass audience of mobile devices with limited energy storage to begin with. It's not just about carbon footprint. Battery life matters.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoOh sure; I'm 100% in favor of obsessing over power efficiency in the name of keeping your device running cool or making the battery last longer. I intended only to say that at least phones and laptops are, as far as I can see, basically irrelevant for climate/grid-power purposes.
- bsder 5y ago> In general, computers just aren't that bad. As long as you aren't part of the crypto ecosystem. The crypto stuff, OTOH, burns an enormous amount of energy--by design.
- adhesive_wombat 5y agoThe other thing about it is that if you could make it use radically less energy, it wouldn't save a joule: the same amount of energy would be used to just mine more of it.
- taeric 5y agoThis same thought experiment used to crack me up with lights. Folks would think "just turn your lights off earlier to save energy." This really fit in the mentality of "you have to suffer to gain." The math isn't even hard. Switching from 60W bulbs down to an LED, which is ~9W, any effort to save energy on the old lights by turning them off is laughably misguided.
- aspenmayer 5y agoThis kind of thinking comes from a scarcity mindset that is overly concerned with efficiency, when we already have record-breaking efficiency in many domains compared to only 5 or 10 years ago. What was the point of those efficiency gains and engineering efforts and research expenditures, if we can’t even use the toys we made with the cool tech we invented? What’s the point of doing better if we’re shamed for the enterprise itself, after outdoing ourselves?