3 ms·
People just don't learn. We've known that it was important to keep petty crime in control since NYC's "No Broken Windows" policies of the 1990s.
by zozbot234 5y ago
People just don't learn. We've known that it was important to keep petty crime in control since NYC's "No Broken Windows" policies of the 1990s.
- kilotaras 5y agoAFAIK there's not much causal evidence for supporting NYCs "No Broken Window" policies effect. Phasing out of lead has more explanatory power.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> We’ve known that it was important to keep petty crime in control since NYC’s “No Broken Windows” policies of the 1990s. Actually, it is clear that that local policy either did nothing at all but was simply adopted at the right time to be given local credit for broader demographic (e.g., population bulge aging out of the main crime-driving age band), economic, and environmental (e.g., lead exposure) factors, or it was so successful that it somehow managed to effect places outside of New York across the country that didn’t adopt similar policies.
- dllthomas 5y agoThe "people don't learn" phrasing is particularly amusing, since the disagreement seems to be between those who "learned" once and those who "learned" twice (leaving aside whether what was "learned" in either case was right or wrong).
- swearwolf 5y agoLiving in a place where you see crime and decay all around you, but the data doesn’t back up what you see with your eyes, you really start to question the quality of the data and the conclusions built on top of it.
- PolygonSheep 5y ago> it somehow managed to effect places outside of New York across the country that didn’t adopt similar policies. I definitely remember "tough on crime" being nationally popular (not just in NYC) in both parties through the '90s. Even if it wasn't called "broken windows policing". Obviously some of the Bratton/Giuliani policies were specifically tailored to NYC and not really applicable elsewhere (no need to crack down on subway fare evasion in Houston for example) but the general sentiment of "the police should aggressively enforce all laws and lock all criminals up" was extremely popular. This is not to say that any of this was right, or good, or just, or why crime fell or whatever. But it was definitely popular in the '90s outside of NYC.
- azth 5y agoThere's a reason punishments are necessary, even if they might seem harsh.