2 ms·
For historical context: When IBM and others did this in the past, the decision basically outsourced the environmental pain to other countries, because those ch
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
For historical context:
When IBM and others did this in the past, the decision basically outsourced the environmental pain to other countries, because those chemicals were going to be made by someone somewhere.
A more advanced discussion on the topic might be along the lines of:
“if we know that this material will be produced somewhere in the world, is it not best to put our brightest minds on how to most effectively deal with the waste stream? The added costs of mitigation should equal additional tariffs on the same product in countries that ignore environmental impact.”
This is one of the observed failures of globalization: the government incentivized manufacturing to make other places suffer forgetting that we all share the same planets, and that the wealthy/educated countries should be leading the way on how to ‘best’ manufacture and deal with waste streams.
- mschuster91 5y agoWell, that's the reason why the West doesn't have much silicon or other environmentally damaging production any more - even leaving the obvious question of labor cost and employee rights aside, environmental compliance is expensive. The Silicon Valley as a whole is at the sad top of the Superfund sites count [1] for a reason. [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2019/09/silicon-valley-full-superfund-sites/598531/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2019/09/silic...
- welterde 5y agoThat's not entirely accurate. Chemical industry is still huge in the West (BASF - currently the largest chemical company in the world - for example has the largest contained chemical production site in the world in Ludwigshafen; with smaller sites in Antwerpen and some in the US). The two largest high-purity silicon producers produce their product in the US (REC) and Germany (Wacker). There are still many trailing-node semiconductor fabs left (Global Foundries, ST, NXP, TI, etc.).
- colechristensen 5y agoA ... or perhaps the central idea of free trade is that we can all be better off and get the most out of our effort by producing the most of a thing in a region that has conditions best suited to produce that thing efficiently. Makes sense, some places have lots of mineral resources, some places are great for grazing cattle, some places specialize and have a lot of expertise in producing textiles or.. whatever else. These days though a big driver for the cost savings of globalized products are things like lax environmental regulations or ability to mistreat and exploit workforces.