4 ms·
Just imagine getting pwned by malware bundled in a calculator...
by sph 5y ago
Just imagine getting pwned by malware bundled in a calculator...
- nix23 5y agoWhat is the connection here? Why would you install the calculator not coming from your distribution?
- sph 5y agoBecause there is a push for software developers to be able to package directly for end users. Without devolving into the usual flame war of whether it's a good idea or not, once you install any piece of software you incur some security risks. It's not like distro maintainers are a 100% guarantee there won't be a backdoor in the binary, and compiling software from source doesn't free you from risks either, unless you code-review everything you install. My point is, containerisation on Linux isn't necessarily slow—in fact it's unnoticeable if implemented correctly—and I prefer to default to having a decent amount of security by containerising as much software as I can, whatever the origin. Including, and especially software like the calculator, since it should not be able to do anything more than show a GUI and add numbers together.
- nix23 5y agoThat's not what i asked, why do you trust a no name dev more then the distro your kernel is coming from? And do you really think flatpack prevents you from running packed malware?
- wander_homer 5y agoWhy do you assume the flatpak comes from a no name dev? My calculator flatpak comes from the same people who wrote it, and I obviously trust them, otherwise I wouldn't be using their application. So why should I trust them less than my distribution?
- nix23 5y agoEver used npm?
- wander_homer 5y agoNo, and how is that even relevant?
- nix23 5y ago>So why should I trust them less than my distribution? Just use google -> npm malware
- wander_homer 5y agoI said I'm not using npm. With my calculator flatpak I only have to trust one person and to a much lesser degree, because they declared that the calculator can't access my personal files to begin with. The same app in my distribution repository has full read-write access to all my users files, network access and much more. So yeah, I trust it more. Distribution maintainers are nothing but a middle man, which don't even audit the code they package, so there's nothing I gain from them.
- wander_homer 5y agoIn my particular case: I don't want to wait months or even years for updates to arrive in my distribution. With the Flatpak version I get updates usually on the same day they are published, since the Flatpak is also maintained by the calculator developers, and I also get a calculator which can't access my ssh keys or the internet, due to sandboxing. And in case of any breakage, I can also quickly roll back to the last version. Without flatpak I'd need to use some rolling release distribution, where not just a few applications get updated quickly, but also the rest of the system, which I'm not interested in.