3 ms·
Like with many things in my lifetime I think perfection was achieved in this area at least a couple of decades ago. As the article states, nobody actually cared
by globular-toast 5y ago
Like with many things in my lifetime I think perfection was achieved in this area at least a couple of decades ago. As the article states, nobody actually cared whether a DVD had Dolby or DTS on it. There was this perception that DTS must have been higher quality, so you'd imagine it was (and often the DTS version sounded louder due to calibration issues).
Our relentless insistence on progression has led to gimmicks like Dolby Atmos. It really doesn't add much of value to anything. It's just a new logo to put on cheap plastic soundbars that will be in landfills in a decade.
When you watch movies from the early days of Dolby Digital in the 80s you can tell that progress has been made since then. But watch a movie from the early 2000s and it will sound just like one today. In fact, they often sound better. Examples are Lord of the Rings, Spider-man 2 and War of the Worlds.
Why can't we just be happy?
- Thlom 5y agoI worked in the Cinema industry when Dolby Atmos were introduced. It was a pretty big upgrade and quality assurance for each auditorium were strict. Speakers had to be installed all over the roof and more speakers had to be added all around the auditorium. So in a Cinema Atmos can be pretty great, but how you can translate this to a home theatre setting is beyond me.
- aspenmayer 5y agoHow were installs like this calibrated? How are home installs calibrated, for that matter? Open source solutions/recommendations especially appreciated.
- dtx1 5y agoMy denon receiver comes with a microphone and an integrated calibration tool
- izacus 5y agoFor home installs the AV Receiver driving the speakers comes with (usually a proprietary) function to calibrate based on your sitting position. I'm not sure if there's many opensource solutions - the quality of autocalibration is a big differentiating feature between AVR OEMs.
- nitrogen 5y agoCheck out Duff Room Correction for an old school open source option. There's also Room EQ Wizard, but that is not open source. In high end home theaters there were proprietary installer tools like JBL's ARCOS (which I worked on). And there are pro calibration tools like Smaart. In any case it's some combination of measurement, gain calibration, delay compensation, and generation of FIR or IIR filters to control frequency and phase response. Followed by subjective tweaking by the installer. Plus maybe some secret sauce for various things in the proprietary algorithms.
- izacus 5y agoYou translate it by using Dolby Atmos setup (which people are doing for a few years now and is available at home as well). For cheap setups, people bounce sound off the ceiling while for better setups people install speakers into the ceiling. Automatic speaker calibration for a given room is pretty much a standard feature on AVRs today so that part is also taken care off. It's not quite the same as cinema, but there's still a massive market for people that want more than farting out of cheap phone speakers.
- Jaruzel 5y agoMy setup is FAR from cheap: DENON 13 channel AVR, Monitor Audios all round, and KEF upfiring Atmos, all in a nice 7.1.4 setup (with a 100" projected image). I went with upfiring, as I didn't want to hack loads of holes in the original ceiling of my 90 year old house. Yeah they are not as good as in-ceiling speakers, but I wouldn't say upfiring is always for 'cheap setups' - sometimes you have to just live with the restrictions you have.
- izacus 5y agoAh, sure, I didn't mean "cheap" as in "low quality" but more cheap in terms of "don't need to hire builders to drill holes in your ceiling". (I'm using upfiring system as well due to same restrictions :D )