3 ms·
> the reformed framework attempted to remedy achievement gaps by urging public schools to remove certain accelerated math tracks from middle school education. B
by josephcsible 5y ago
> the reformed framework attempted to remedy achievement gaps by urging public schools to remove certain accelerated math tracks from middle school education. Boaler’s guidelines have become a basis for a statewide push to move these classes, specifically Algebra I, out of middle school.
Closing the achievement gap is only a good thing if you do it by helping the lower-achieving kids, not by leaving them alone and just holding back the higher-achieving kids, which is what this would do. This sounds like something out of Harrison Bergeron.
- a9h74j 5y agoThat passage does not unambiguously say this, but is Algebra I in middle school now considered accelerated in California?
- gnicholas 5y agoYeah, they discuss Algebra I in 8th grade as being advanced. The push is to delay everyone from taking it until 9th grade. This was something that caught me off-guard when we started learning about schools for our kids. We've lived in the heart of Silicon Valley, in very pricey school districts. One school bragged about how they had just implemented super-duper accelerated math, where some students took Algebra I in 7th grade. That was surprising and unimpressive to me. I grew up in Sacramento and in our GATE program, Algebra I in 7th grade was the norm. The truly advanced kids were taking calculus in 9th grade. There are many kids around Palo Alto who are advanced in math. But almost none of them are picking it up in the public schools. In fact, there are parents in Palo Alto who have gone so far as to sue PAUSD in order to get advanced math instruction. One lawsuit was settled (the kid was allowed to advance, and the parents were given thousands of dollars), and another lawsuit is pending.
- zozbot234 5y ago> Closing the achievement gap is only a good thing if you do it by helping the lower-achieving kids Modern "educators" see actual teaching as demeaning to their role; their schtick is that every student should just be learning their math by themselves. You can imagine how well this works for the unlucky 'lower-achievers', who for social reasons may not even have any alternative support from their family or community either.
- danbmil99 5y ago+1 for the Vonnegut reference Tldr Harrison Bergeron is a satire of the desire to make all outcomes equal. Worth a read.
- hw-guy 5y agoThe California education establishment seems to think of "Harrison Bergeron" not as a warning, but an instruction manual.