By "Good For Me" I don't just mean productivity-wise, I mean a positive and rewarding experience. And frankly I do not know whether I would enjoy using Emacs. (

By "Good For Me" I don't just mean productivity-wise, I mean a positive and rewarding experience. And frankly I do not know whether I would enjoy using Emacs. (I similarly don't know whether I would enjoy playing music.) But I know that learning Emacs is a chore. I did not enjoy having to relearn common interaction concepts like windows, frames, yank, kill. I did not enjoy retraining muscle-memory (or modifying bindings) because editing and navigation shortcuts don't match the standards that have been codified in every other desktop text area. I did not enjoy the endless search for the right distribution/mode/extension to solve a particular problem. I did not enjoy that none of these are generalizable skills that transfer beyond the esoteric priesthood of Emacs use. I liked the core concepts in principle and I enjoyed the new perspective it provided, like peeking into an alternate universe with a parallel evolutionary path. Eventually life intervened and I had to retreat back to editors that take minutes to learn rather than hours or days. I suspect I'll give it another go someday when I can afford to devote the better part of a weekend to it, perhaps when the kids are older.