4 ms·
A Russian debt default looks almost inevitable
- mountainriver 5y agoI’m sure Putin can cover it out if his own pocket with all the money he’s been siphoning. Time to repo his assets
- tpmx 5y agoCan we learn from previous wars/incidents what might happen to the western stock markets? Is it at all transferrable? Like, what happened during WW2, the cuba crisis, the vietnam war, etc?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Epiphany21 5y ago>Can we learn from previous wars/incidents If previous wars/incidents are any indicator, no.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI think this would be a historical first for default by a country with funds to pay, but having those funds frozen by the creditors.
- StanislavPetrov 5y agoThe Ruble is today trading at virtually the same level it was before the invasion. "Western" governments are desperately trying to engineer a default to further damage Russia's reputation, but it won't be for lack of funds. Russia is the most resource rich country on earth, from natural gas to fertilizer and beyond. Jawboning aside, the interdependent global economy depends on resources sourced in Russia, which they will continue to purchase. https://wise.com/us/currency-converter/rub-to-usd-rate https://wise.com/us/currency-converter/rub-to-usd-rate
- mike00632 5y agoThe Ruble isn't allowed to be freely traded so that exchange rate is bunk.
- mediumsmart 5y agoHere is how they made this bunk up: The Bank of Russia has resumed gold purchases this week, but more importantly, the regulator is doing so at a fixed price of 5,000 rubles ($59) per 1 gram between March 28 and June 30, raising the possibility of Russia returning to the gold standard for the first time in over a century. If the country takes the next step, as has been proposed this week, to sell its commodities priced in rubles, these combined moves could have huge implications for the ruble, the US dollar, and the global economy. To get some answers, RT spoke to precious metals analyst Ronan Manly at BullionStar Singapore. — Why is setting a fixed price for gold in rubles significant? By offering to buy gold from Russian banks at a fixed price of 5,000 rubles per gram, the Bank of Russia has both linked the ruble to gold and, since gold trades in US dollars, set a floor price for the ruble in terms of the US dollar. We can see this linkage in action since Friday 25 March when the Bank of Russia made the fixed price announcement. The ruble was trading at around 100 to the US dollar at that time, but has since strengthened and is nearing 80 to the US dollar. Why? Because gold has been trading on international markets at about US$62 per gram which is equivalent to (5,000 / 62) = about 80.5, and markets and arbitrage traders have now taken note, driving the RUB/USD exchange rate higher. So the ruble now has a floor to the US dollars, in terms of gold. But gold also has a floor, so to speak, because 5,000 rubles per gram is 155,500 rubles per troy ounce of gold, and with a RUB/USD floor of about 80, that’s a gold price of around $1,940. And if the Western paper gold markets of LBMA/COMEX try to drive the US dollar gold price lower, they will have to try to weaken the ruble as well or else the paper manipulations will be out in the open. Additionally, with the new gold to ruble linkage, if the ruble continues to strengthen (for example due to demand created by obligatory energy payments in rubles), this will also be reflected in a stronger gold price. — What does it mean for oil? Russia is the world’s largest natural gas exporter and the world’s third largest oil exporter. We are seeing right now that Putin is demanding that foreign buyers (importers of Russian gas) must pay for this natural gas using rubles. This immediately links the price of natural gas to rubles and (because of the fixed link to gold) to the gold price. So Russian natural gas is now linked via the ruble to gold. The same can now be done with Russian oil. If Russia begins to demand payment for oil exports with rubles, there will be an immediate indirect peg to gold (via the fixed price ruble – gold connection). Then Russia could begin accepting gold directly in payment for its oil exports. In fact, this can be applied to any commodities, not just oil and natural gas. — What does that mean for the price of gold? By playing both sides of the equation, i.e. linking the ruble to gold and then linking energy payments to the ruble, the Bank of Russia and the Kremlin are fundamentally altering the entire working assumptions of the global trade system while accelerating change in the global monetary system. This wall of buyers in search of physical gold to pay for real commodities could certainly torpedo and blow up the paper gold markets of the LBMA and COMEX. The fixed peg between the ruble and gold puts a floor on the RUB/USD rate but also a quasi-floor on the US dollar gold price. But beyond this, the linking of gold to energy payments is the main event. While increased demand for rubles should continue to strengthen the RUB/USD rate and show up as a higher gold price, due to the fixed ruble - gold linkage, if Russia begins to accept gold directly as a payment for oil, then this would be a new paradigm shift for the gold price as it would link the oil price directly to the gold price. For example, Russia could start by specifying that it will now accept 1 gram of gold per barrel of oil. It doesn’t have to be 1 gram but would have to be a discounted offer to the current crude benchmark price so as to promote take up, e.g. 1.2 grams per barrel. Buyers would then scramble to buy physical gold to pay for Russian oil exports, which in turn would create huge strains in the paper gold markets of London and New York where the entire ‘gold price’ discovery is based on synthetic and fractionally-backed cash-settled unallocated ‘gold’ and gold price ‘derivatives. — What does it mean for the ruble? Linking the ruble to gold via the Bank of Russia’s fixed price has now put a floor under the RUB/USD rate, and thereby stabilized and strengthened the ruble. Demanding that natural gas exports are paid for in rubles (and possibly oil and other commodities down the line) will again act as stabilization and support. If a majority of the international trading system begins accepting these rubles for commodity payments arrangements, this could propel the Russian ruble to becoming a major global currency. At the same time, any move by Russia to accept direct gold for oil payments will cause more international gold to flow into Russian reserves, which would also strengthen the balance sheet of the Bank of Russia and in turn strengthen the ruble. Talk of a formal gold standard for the ruble might be premature, but a gold-backed ruble must be something the Bank of Russia has considered. — What does it mean for other currencies? The global monetary landscape is changing rapidly and central banks around the world are obviously taking note. Western sanctions such as the freezing of the majority of Russia’s foreign exchange reserves while trying to sanction Russian gold have now made it obvious that property rights on FX reserves held abroad may not be respected, and likewise, that foreign central bank gold held in vault locations such as at the Bank of England and the New York Fed, is not beyond confiscation. Other non-Western governments and central banks will therefore be taking a keen interest in Russia linking the ruble to gold and linking commodity export payments to the ruble. In other words, if Russia begins to accept payment for oil in gold, then other countries may feel the need to follow suit. Look at who, apart from the US, are the world’s largest oil and natural gas producers - Iran, China, Saudi Arabia, UAE, Qatar. Obviously, all of the BRICS countries and Eurasian countries are also following all of this very closely. If the demise of the US dollar is nearing, all of these countries will want their currencies to be beneficiaries of a new multi-lateral monetary order. — What does this mean for the US dollar? Since 1971, the global reserve status of the US dollar has been underpinned by oil, and the petrodollar era has only been possible due to both the world’s continued use of US dollars to trade oil and the USA’s ability to prevent any competitor to the US dollar. But what we are seeing right now looks like the beginning of the end of that 50-year system and the birth of a new gold and commodity backed multi-lateral monetary system. The freezing of Russia’s foreign exchange reserves has been the trigger. The giant commodity strong countries of the world such as China and the oil exporting nations may now feel that now is the time to move to a new more equitable monetary system. It’s not a surprise, they have been discussing it for years. While it’s still too early to say how the US dollar will be affected, it will come out of this period weaker and less influential than before. — What are the ramifications? The Bank of Russia’s move to link the ruble to gold and link commodity payments to the ruble is a paradigm shift that the Western media has not really yet grasped. As the dominos fall, these events could reverberate in different ways. Increased demand for physical gold. Blowups in the paper gold markets. A revalued gold price. A shift away from the US dollar. Increased bilateral trade in commodities among non-Western counties in currencies other than the US dollar.
- nine_zeros 5y agoSure, a default will affect bond lending. But does it affect trade for a large resource rich country like Russia? It's not like Russia needs bonds with external investors. They just need to be able to trade. How does a default matter in such a case?
- rasz 5y agoCould US start confiscating ships at sea carrying Russian resources?
- nine_zeros 5y agoWhy wouldn't Russia do the same to US ships then?
- rasz 5y agoDoes US owe Russia money?
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>America and its Western allies had frozen roughly half of the country’s $630bn foreign-exchange reserves. That's a lot of Russian money that the US has possession of and wont give back
- neilwilson 5y agoWhat do you think 'US dollar foreign reserves' are? A dollar is a promise that the US will supply goods and services in the future to whoever holds it. Hence "full faith and credit". All money is debt. The West defaulted on its debt first, and other countries in the world holding Dollars, Euros and Pounds as 'reserves' noticed that the West can stop them using those Dollars, Euros and Pounds whenever they feel like it. It's not just Russia's "credit rating" that has been affected here. Expect countries shipping their exports to the West to demand real things in return, not just financial promises that may not be delivered.
- 5y ago
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIt is unclear to me what a default is supposed to indicate when the the collectors are the ones holding and freezing the assets that easily could be used to pay it. Traditionally, the damage of default is that it demonstrates that your fundamental economics are so poor you can't make your payments. In this case it means that the creditors refuse to allow payment.
- user3939382 5y agoI have no idea what venue this would be adjudicated in but the legal concept here may be force majeure: https://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/force+majeure https://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/force+majeure
- monkeydreams 5y ago> It is unclear to me what a default is supposed to indicate when the the collectors are the ones holding and freezing the assets that easily could be used to pay it. Should an alleged thief be able to pay his lawyers with the proceeds of that theft? Should a charged murderer inherit their victim's property so they can defend the murder charges? Should Russia be free of their obligation to pay their debts just because the nations (not the organisations) to which they owe the debt are implementing punative measures due to an alleged illegal act?
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIm not in debating the morality, but rather asking what markets will make of this new type of default. Default is bad because being too poor to pay up scares away creditors. If Russia maintains the ability to pay the debts to creditors when allowed, how will different creditors feel about that? Traditional default is undesirable because of what it means. It remains to be seen what this default will mean.
- atoav 5y agoWhether one cannot buy in the village store because they A.) have no money or B.) sexually harassed the grocerers daughter is functionally the same: They cannot buy there anymore. Or framed differently: There are certain preconditions someone has to meet before you can do transactions with them. Money is one of those preconditions, but not the only one.
- mitchbob 5y agoArchived: https://archive.ph/lbMc6 https://archive.ph/lbMc6