3 ms·
I do like the idea of using colors to indicate function, but I would be concerned that they draw attention to themselves. Sometimes that is a good thing, but so
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
I do like the idea of using colors to indicate function, but I would be concerned that they draw attention to themselves. Sometimes that is a good thing, but sometimes it's really distracting from the content. I think Reddit's redesign if a good example of this going wrong. It's like a they hired Jackson Pollock to do the design, with colored buttons and doodads everywhere. It's something I think about a lot with my crappy-ass web design efforts.
As an accessibility thing, I have fairly large hands, and really struggle with the sort of tiny buttons shown in this GUI. I semi-frequently have to use websites in desktop mode so I can zoom in to actually press buttons. Not a great experience, and also not something app designers seem to consider.
> Sometimes feeling fast, is more important than actually being fast. This is especially the case when publishing a new post or comment.
> When publishing content on FL, you had to wait until the server successfully responded before you were allowed to do something else. Whether consciously or not, these sorts of penalties for interaction naturally discourage future interactions.
I think when submitting things is one of the times actually taking a moment can feel satisfactory. Returning immediately can feel flimsy and unreliable, like "did it really happen?" and then you refresh and don't see your content.
- pketh 5y ago> I do like the idea of using colors to indicate function, but I would be concerned that they draw attention to themselves > with colored buttons and doodads everywhere I agree, functional colors are not a solution that work for everyone, and also requires a lot of diligence and restraint to not turn into a birthday cake mess (something harder for large corps like reddit) > really struggle with the sort of tiny buttons shown in this GUI It's hard to develop a UI that works for touch and doesn't look clumsy when you've got a mouse. The solution we use here is to visually size the buttons for desktop, but have an invisible padding around them be clickable > Returning immediately can feel flimsy and unreliable, like "did it really happen?" The way we address this is to show your comment appended to the comments list, or to show your post added to your journal. In this case we're optimizing for the joy that comes from the immediate feedback of I pushed submit and now my content is real. There's def room for more fun florishes in some apps like confetti etc when you do something, but those are a better fit for games or for rarer interactions imo (ideally leaving comments is a common action that some will do multiple times a day)
- davidivadavid 5y agoUsing colors to convey state/semantics is also a big accessibility no-no, fyi.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoIf it's only way you convey it. Using colors to further emphasize state or semantics is pretty great. Traffic lights is a good model of how that can work.
- pketh 5y agoYup and in this case everything still has icons and labels. The color here is more akin to optional progressive enhancement
- davidivadavid 5y agoBut the icons are for individual actions rather than the semantic grouping the colors convey, no?
- pketh 5y agoYes and those actions can be understood independently of their grouping
- davidivadavid 5y ago> If it's only way you convey it. Exactly. That's why your traffic lights example is puzzling to me? They're a notorious example of a case of something that can very easily be (and often is) ambiguous.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoHow is a traffic light ambiguous? The stop and go lights are physically distinct lamps. The top light means stop, the bottom light means go.