5 ms·
It's unclear that battery scaling will happen in time to reach sharply negative carbon emissions, or that solar and wind will meet future energy demands. Our k
by hedora 5y ago
It's unclear that battery scaling will happen in time to reach sharply negative carbon emissions, or that solar and wind will meet future energy demands. Our kids need to put all the carbon back in the ground, which means we need to put the first 10-20% back ourselves. That would double global energy consumption for decades, assuming we started today.
Your supply chain carbon arguments have a fundamental flaw: Transportation and the grid need to decarbonize regardless of which technology the power plant uses.
Solar panel production is being bootstrapped with coal based power plants. That doesn't imply coal plants will be needed moving forward, or that industrial (bursty, scheduled consumption) electicity will be scarce.
The fact that US nuclear plants are riduculously economically inefficient doesn't imply plants in the rest of the world are similarly bad, or that the technology is infeasible. The US environmental movement intentionally sabotaged the industry through the second half of the 20th century. Also, efficient, safe nuclear plants have been operated for decades in other countries.
Anyway, we're clearly headed to a situation where we have effectively infinite clean electricity during the day, thanks to solar.
The real questions are whether energy storage devices are cheaper than nuclear, and how economical it is to time shift energy-intensive industrial processes (basically building 2-3x more factory, but idling it at night).
I'm hoping there is some bursty carbon capture technology on the horizon, where buying more equipment for a higher burst capture rate is cheap, so the electricity produced for the quarter of the day where there's a massive surplus isn't wasted.
We need to do that anyway, and it would greatly reduce nuclear, hydro and energy storage demand.
- ncmncm 5y agoCost for storage is falling even faster than solar or wind ever did. All that is unclear is what will end up cheapest, in any particular area. In many places, the poorer round-trip efficiency of chemical synthesis (hydrogen, ammonia, hydrocarbons) is offset by the massive usefulness of synthesizer output after the tanks are full. That is, when the tanks have been topped off, the excess output generates revenue. Solar generating capacity has become so cheap that needing 2x, 3x, 4x more, for whatever reason, is no blocker.
- HyperRational 5y ago
- hedora 5y agoEven if batteries and solar get another 10x cheaper, that's not enough to make it through winter in some populated areas. A whole home backup battery is $10K's, and likely stores under 24 hours of normal usage. Buying 90 of those per house (for three months of power backup) would cost millions per house today. A bright overcast day in California can easily drop solar output by 50-75%. Up north, it's much worse, and those days can come in multi-month bursts. Much of the US south will be uninhabitable according to current climate projections, which increases demand up north, creating distribution problems that haven't been solved. Also 40+ state megastorms are becoming common in the US. What happens if the whole continent is cold and cloudy at the same time? I guess you're propsing synthetic natural gas, or similar?
- ncmncm 5y agoBatteries are the most expensive storage medium. No utility will use those to keep more than a few minutes or hours of backup. Pumped hydro is cheap and reliable, but each site has a strict upper limit on how much it can store. Synthetic anhydrous ammonia, and hydrogen, are the favored utility-scale media. They can be stored, but more importantly they can also be shipped in from the tropics, and most importantly can be sold when the tanks are full.
- sudosysgen 5y agoAmmonia is not great for shipping to due low gravimetric energy density. At the same time, ammonia cycle efficiency in a fuel cell is low, and fuel cells are expensive. Hydrogen is a shipping nightmare, as you well know. So at this point we are comparing the cost of a full NH3/H2 backup energy generation, plus the cost of a full renewable energy grid with at least 50% overproduction and hours of battery storage, plus the cost of storing 100 million tons of NH3/NH2, as well as the cost of NH3/NH2 production, and funding of generally idle overproduction in countries with a better climate (!!)
- 7952 5y agoScaling battery storage does seem easier than scaling nuclear. They are mass producible as small modules and can utilise less skilled labour in factories. Grid scale developments have negligible civil engineering requirments, ridiculously quick to build and can work on small or large sites. They are easy for investors to understand and insure. And the underlying technology can piggy back on the cell phone industry and will be required for electric cars. Also, by the time we get to nuclear scale out it may well be competing with hydrogen also.
- Manuel_D 5y agoI don't think people understand the scale of storage required to make decarbonization through renewables feasible. The USA consumes 500GWh of electricity every hour. And electricity is only about a third of total energy consumption. 8 GWh is one minute of electricity storage, 20 seconds of total energy storage. We'll need and estimated 3 weeks of storage to decarbonize through renewables: https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2018/03/01/12-hours-energy-storage-80-percent-wind-solar/ https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2018/03/01/12-hours-energy-stora... By comparison, the US just needs to build four nuclear plants for each one that exists currently. To achieve a 100% nuclear electricity grid. A bit less than that for decarbonization since we have some hydroelectric power.
- runarberg 5y agoJust four new nuclear power plants for every existing plant is still a lot of plants. There are 93 active reactors in the USA today. That means we need to build between 350 to 400 more reactors. There are currently only 2 new reactors under construction and 11 more planned (6 of these are NuScale modes with only 77 MW Capacity). The last reactor to open was at the Watts Bar plant in Tennessee in 2016, and before that 1996 in the same plant. Both of these reactors started construction in the 1970s. If we “just” need 350-400 more, it is gonna take us ages to get there.
- Manuel_D 5y agoBuilding nuclear plants at the same rate as we did in the 1970s would get us there in 3 decades. You write as though this is some Herculean task, but if the US didn't reduce the pace of nuclear construction in the 1980s we would have had a decarbonized grid by 2000. It's not just hypothetically possible, this pace of nuclear construction has historical precedent. By comparison, nobody has any realistic plans to decarbonize fully through renewables. The plan is to burn gas for ~40% of our electricity when intermittent sources aren't producing, and cross our fingers while we hope for a miraculous breakthrough in energy storage. Plans to decarbonize through renewables assumes that hydrogen storage, thermal batteries, or something else will provide effectively free energy storage.