4 ms·
The engineering reasons and legal reasons reinforce each other in an endless cycle. Engines are of stone-age complexity because the FAA says they must be, and t
by ryandrake 5y ago
The engineering reasons and legal reasons reinforce each other in an endless cycle. Engines are of stone-age complexity because the FAA says they must be, and the FAA says they must be because safety, and the stone-age engines are safe because nobody takes risks and they remain in the stone-age. We're talking about an industry where you can tell which piston airplanes are new because they are fuel injected instead of carbureted!!
This is one of the reasons why I think almost all of the innovation in GA, including modern powerplants, electronic ignitions, advanced avionics electronic systems, and even safety systems, is happening in the Experimental category, not in certified factory-built airplanes. If I owned a Cessna and decided to so much as run a USB charger out to the panel, the FAA would come down on me like a ton of bricks. But I could replace the engine monitor or autopilot on my E/AB category airplane, and the FAA doesn't even care. Hell, I could replace the entire engine with something I invented in my basement, and all I have to do is re-do Phase I testing.
- sokoloff 5y agoI agree with you in effect, but disagree in terms of mechanism. The FAA doesn’t say you have to use any particular tech; instead they say the burden of proof is on the applicant for an STC to prove an equivalent level of safety and no degradation in performance that would be relevant to certification of the original article. If you want to add a turbo-normalizer to an engine originally certified as normally aspirated, there’s a process to get that approved. Replace one magneto with electronic ignition? There’s at least one group with an STC for that. (BTW, your USB charger example is a minor modification, able to signed off by an A&P.)
- Stratoscope 5y agoFor those unfamiliar with the terminology, A&P stands for airframe and power plant. An A&P mechanic is someone licensed to work on the airframe and engine.
- coryrc 5y agoWhy doesn't our safety matter?
- throw0101a 5y ago> Engines are of stone-age complexity because the FAA says they must be, and the FAA says they must be because safety, and the stone-age engines are safe because nobody takes risks and they remain in the stone-age. The FAA says no such thing. There are modern FADEC piston engines: * https://www.lycoming.com/engines https://www.lycoming.com/engines * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austro_Engine_E4 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austro_Engine_E4 and you can new planes with them: * https://www.flyingmag.com/we-fly-diamond-da40-ng/ https://www.flyingmag.com/we-fly-diamond-da40-ng/ It's just there are (over) 100K pre-FADEC planes out there with perfectly fine "stone-age" engines, and few people want to spend US$ 40K on a new engine when they can overhaul their current one for half the price when the time comes.