5 ms·
"It will be a heck of a lot more effective" I do write letters to my representatives and such. Unfortunately, I think either action (writing letters or comment
by giantg2 5y ago
"It will be a heck of a lot more effective"
I do write letters to my representatives and such. Unfortunately, I think either action (writing letters or commenting here) have near zero impact. In my experience, you get a canned response. If you're lucky, that response actually talks about the concerns you raised, but usually is just loosely related and is mostly fluff. Sometimes it's completely unrelated. Sometimes they simply ignore you and never respond at all.
It feels like more of our government is broken or perverted than is actually functioning correctly and beneficially.
- zasdffaa 5y agoMy own MP (I'm in the UK) has been willing to respond to my letters on climate change but not actually do anything. My plan, when time permits, is to publish the responses, and especially the lack of responses. Public bodies hate bad publicity. Maybe you can do the same.
- giantg2 5y agoI actually contacted an investigative journalist about some of the problems we were having (rights violations, judicial incompetence, police lying in court). Basically, the response was that they'd like the info and documents if it fits with a larger story, but that there were so many bigger issues that this story wouldn't be published by itself. Also they ran a story about the incompetence of the magistrates in the prior year or so (magistrates here don't have to pass the Bar or have a legal degree).
- hn_version_0023 5y ago> It feels like more of our government is broken or perverted than is actually functioning correctly and beneficially. Yes. It’s my understanding the goal of the US government is to maintain the status quo. It doesn’t much matter that the status quo is a Kafka-esque dystopian nightmare. It’s working as intended. In other words: I’m closing this bug report; working as intended
- giantg2 5y agoTrue. I guess the real bug is that we are generally lied to by teachers and other adults while growing up. So we expect this just, righteous, effective system, only to realize it's full of incompetence, contradictions, and even corruption.
- Pulcinella 5y agoI mean, I tried to “drop some truth” on my high school students when I was a teacher, but reactionary administrators and politicians (and sometimes parents) don’t like it when you try to “brainwash” students (I.e. say anything other than how the current system is natural and perfect).
- hn_version_0023 5y agoI think that’s a symptom too. The root cause seems to be the notion that children must be “protected from the truth” so they can lead a carefree youth. Then kids turn 18 and the mask drops and — at least for me — the number of WTFs is never ending. I’m 46yro and I still don’t understand why I was told so many lies… except of course I do understand: adults don’t want to explain their shittyness to a bunch of kids. Just imagine if our collective parents had to deal with a generational outcry demanding they stop fucking around, stop stealing from our future, stop lying, etc. Society as we know it would end, necessarily replaced by something more just. Can’t have that! The status quo it is then. FML; YMMV
- 8note 5y agoYou can argue that either is a side effect. Hiding the status quo is something you'd do to maintain the status quo, just as much as not knowing the status quo reduces your wants to get away from it
- hn_version_0023 5y agoSo what’s the bug? How can we identify and fix the problem?
- carapace 5y ago> It feels like more of our government is broken or perverted than is actually functioning correctly and beneficially. I don't mean to excuse any of the B.S. that's going down, but I feel it's important to take the long view, to see the thing in the light of history. Not for nothing is it said, "Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all the others.", eh?
- bllguo 5y ago1. the history of democracy is very short, it's no foregone conclusion that it is the best option regardless of pithy quotes from Churchill or what we would like to believe (and yes I know that "best" and "worst" are doing a lot of work in our statements) 2. there are many implementations of democracy possible and extant, so even if we think democracy is the ideal government that is still no defense of the US
- carapace 5y agoI would say it's the best option so far. Conventional wisdom holds that autocracy is better, if-and-only-if you have a good autocrat. It's said the old women wept when the King of Bhutan decreed Democracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhutanese_democracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhutanese_democracy
- rootusrootus 5y agoIf we're being honest, what reply would actually be expected other than some kind of canned response? Each representative has around 750,000 citizens to represent -- if even a tiny fraction of them write a letter, the representative is going to be inundated. Some senators have 20,000,000 citizens they represent. I'd like to see an attempt to go back to the original 30,000 per rep. We have the technology now to make that entirely feasible.
- giantg2 5y agoOften times I am writing to state reps who represent closer to the 30k number. Also, the reps themselves don't often answer letters, but have aides that can do that based on the reps position.
- nickff 5y ago>"I'd like to see an attempt to go back to the original 30,000 per rep. We have the technology now to make that entirely feasible." I agree that congresspeople and senators represent too many people to do so accurately, but enlarging the congress would cause other problems. Devolving power to the states (and municipalities) would likely be more effective.
- ngngngng 5y agoMike Lee's office always responds to me, but I've yet to get a response that says anything other than "I disagree with you."
- williamscales 5y agolol that's absurd, it's not his job to disagree with you. his job is to listen to you and represent you.
- throwawayboise 5y agoHe obviously cannot agree with everyone. He has his point of view, sold that to a majority of voters, who elected him. I'd rather hear that my representative disagrees with me than receive some BS noncommital answer that dodges the issue or tries to straddle both sides of an issue.
- nickff 5y agoThe fact that the representative's office clearly says it disagrees is great! It means they understand constituents' positions well enough to know whether they are representing their electorate. The bland, nothing replies are a sign that they're not even bothering to register your opinion.
- xoa 5y agoNo, he can absolutely disagree when it comes to political questions. That's literally what they're elected on and the point of indirect democracy is to have dedicated people who can exercise their own judgement using their expertise and resources alongside reacting to constituent concerns. And constituent concerns are not in fact always valid for that matter. Or one set of constituent priorities may conflict with another set. Balancing that kind of thing is a political question. An honest rep's office should certainly take some time to respond to an actual letter and if they don't agree or just plain can't do something give a brief reason as to why (fresh for a new issue raised, could be canned if it's a frequent question but should still represent updated reasoning). But doing so is not wrong. If enough constituents disagree with that, the remedy is to vote that rep out (which would hopefully be easier for outrageous cases like this which do not fall along any typical partisan lines).
- sircastor 5y agoI can't speak to the way the FAA works - as I believe those are appointed positions - for elected officials, every time you write a letter, or a make a phone call and are a constituent of that official, someone is writing down the subject, and your preferences about the matter. And the more people who do it and bring it up, the more time the representative spends on that topic.
- geoduck14 5y agoTry leaving a review on Google maps. It works every time /s