4 ms·
Bureaucracies have huge incentive to keep any status quo as it is. Any change is potentially risky. This is something we can possibly solve by not punishing st
by inglor_cz 5y ago
Bureaucracies have huge incentive to keep any status quo as it is. Any change is potentially risky.
This is something we can possibly solve by not punishing state servants as harshly if they make a decision and something goes wrong. "Something went wrong" is a bad metric for firing people. There should be a pattern of bad behavior before something like that is done.
- paganel 5y ago> This is something we can possibly solve by not punishing state servants as harshly if they make a decision and something goes wrong The way things are going over here in the EU the reverse is true, as in state servants are incentivised to not walk even a millimetre outside of the chosen, legal path for fear of prison time. Now, one would think that the "legal path" is a very large and broad one, but the truth is that it is all in the eye of the beholder, that assessment all depends on who holds the reins of power and if that state servant is on the "good" side (with "us") or on the "bad" side (with "them"). At least that's how things happen in the Eastern part of the EU. More exactly, and as a hypothetical example: one cannot just choose the best tool for the job (or the best services for the job) as a result of a public procurement process because it all depends on the offered price. Doesn't matter if the the opportunity cost savings generating by choosing the slightly more expansive tool/service are an order of magnitude larger compared to said price difference (i.e. between the cheaper but worst model, compared to the more expansive but better model) a state servant in my country can get actual prison time for choosing the more expensive (but better) tool/service. So what happens for state servants that do actually want to get something done while avoiding prison time is to precisely "manicure" the technical requirements that are part of the public procurement process so that the better but the more expensive product wins. It's borderline illegal (and some other public public servants are using this same tactic for really nefarious reasons) but that's how things are.
- bombcar 5y agoThat last part is why you will find products and packages that have weird features that don't really seem to be necessary or in align with the rest of the system. Because you can require that weird feature and then get the "more expensive" product.
- mountainofdeath 5y agoIndeed this is a major problem in public service. Everyone from your local street police officer up the the president of the USA. Nobody cares when things are done correctly and go well, but everyone cares when things go wrong, even if (the hope is) the occurrence is rare. Thus, the entire bureaucracy is setup toward this.
- systemvoltage 5y agoNo, they're always changing for the worse. New regulations get piled up and adopted faster than ever. More procedures and paperwork constantly get into pipelines. When people's job is do X, they will continue to do X even if X is not needed.