6 ms·
A self-authenticating social protocol
- mattdesl 5y agoHow would bluesky address the “political decentralization” aspect that is present in some blockchains? i.e. ensuring the protocol ends up being widely distributed rather than hosted and managed by a centralized few. Cryptocurrencies seem to address this by creating an incentive for any user to validate state and secure the public proofs (PoW/PoS), but I’m interested to hear how bluesky would approach this?
- d110af5ccf 5y agoI don't think you need to. With cryptocurrencies there's a need to obtain global consensus regarding where a coin is transferred from and to in order to prevent double spend. With communications you only need the ability to cryptographically verify the authenticity of the data and who published it. There's no double spend problem. Looking at email, there is an issue with people tending towards a few large providers and with some providers refusing to federate with other ones for various reasons. The former probably isn't possible to solve directly via technical means. The latter is addressed by the described "self-authenticating" aspect. Peer to peer data transfer coupled with cryptographically based identities means an identity isn't tied to a particular provider.
- mattdesl 5y agoWho would host the data? BitTorrent protocol has a notorious “seeder/leecher” problem. And how would that hosting mechanism be resistant to collusion and manipulation? For example, a signature or zero knowledge proof is published onto a social network by the president’s cryptographic identity, how can we (the people viewing the network) verify that the data we see on the network is in fact published by the president, and not a malicious actor who is hosting their own node? At a scale of just one individual, we could easily establish “Person A = public key hash X” and verify that, but at a scale of millions of users it seems you will need some sort of decentralized state/data tracking (like a distributed blockchain ledger).
- d110af5ccf 5y ago> Who would host the data? Anyone who wanted to. If you wanted to make sure your personal data remained available when you turned your computer off or that it could be downloaded quickly then you'd need to arrange for paid hosting. Pick up cheap vps and share it with your family and friends. Whatever. > how would that hosting mechanism be resistant to collusion and manipulation It doesn't need to be, that's the point of using strong cryptography. > it seems you will need some sort of decentralized state/data tracking (like a distributed blockchain ledger) No, you just need to keep track of keys. Your identity is your key. We already do this. Certificate authorities, ssh keys, etc. The issue you're describing is one of using a centralized authority to solve the problem which is hardly the only solution and certainly doesn't require a blockchain.
- mattdesl 5y agoPresumably Bluesky's social media protocol will need to operate on some data/ledger structure, to maintain a large social graph (follower/follows), user records (public key hashes, posts, etc). If too few nodes are hosting this data, it would be malleable to manipulation by the hosts. The same occurs in blockchains that are not widely distributed enough: a blockchain with 5 validators (hosts) is more susceptible to manipulation (i.e. hosts changing records/data for their own gain) than a blockchain with 50K validators, because the cost to control the network becomes exponentially expensive. Strong cryptography has nothing to do with this, and does not prevent this kind of manipulation. Imagine a sort of 51% attack on Bluesky's social graph, in order to manipulate a user's associated public key hash or alter the social graph for some nefarious reason. A blockchain ledger probably is not the only solution, but it does create a strong financial barrier to manipulation (i.e. 51% attacking a widely-distributed PoS blockchain ledger would be prohibitively expensive and short-lived). I am interested if Bluesky is considering these problems and whether they have alternative non-crypto/blockchain solutions.
- csense 5y agoThe "Our Team" link near the end points to https://blueskyweb.org/blog/2-31-2022-initial-bluesky-team https://blueskyweb.org/blog/2-31-2022-initial-bluesky-team Take a close look at that URL, there's a terrible bug in the date handling of whatever CMS they are using.
- d4mi3n 5y agoI don't know anything about bluesky, but I applaud any initiative that could provide a path away from the highly centralized web we find ourselves in today. Also excited to see verifiable computation as an underpinning of this particular initiative. It's a fun topic and technology I haven't seen too broadly explored.
- mawise 5y agoThe linked ecosystem overview[1] is a great exploration of the space. However, there's no mention of IndieAuth[2] in the exploration of decentralized and self-sovereign identity. I'd love to better understand why it's been left out because it seems really appealing in my own explorations of the space. [1] https://gitlab.com/bluesky-community1/decentralized-ecosystem/-/blob/master/README.md https://gitlab.com/bluesky-community1/decentralized-ecosyste... [2] https://indieauth.net/ https://indieauth.net/
- jalcine 5y agoStrong agree. It would even allow for more seamless transitioning between silos and sovereign identities.
- muglug 5y agoThere's no mention here of moderation, a key ingredient to any social network of people who lack real-world ties to each other.
- pfraze 5y agoIt is, and we're talking with people who do trust & safety at Twitter to make sure we're approaching it right. To be clear, we're really in the early stages of the project. This post is just the stuff we have a clear concept about, and even that's just an early prototype (which we'll put on github soon). I could talk about some of the approaches we're looking at for moderation but it's just really early, and I don't want to talk out the wrong end. All I can say is, we talk about it a lot.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 5y agoCould you also talk to the web team about re-adding the vertical scrollbar? It's an important UI element.
- jfengel 5y agoI really appreciate that you're at least thinking about it. Community is a bit like security: you can't just layer it on after building the "cool parts" of your system. The name "trust & safety" makes the parallel even more clear. It's harder to set rigorous definitions for community than it is for security. So it will likely change as the project evolves. But if you ignore it entirely, and just hope it will work itself out, you'll be in a continuous state of crisis-fighting.
- leeroyjenkins11 5y agoIt's hard to take a project that calls for decentralization using twitters trust and safety people as a source. The company that killed a relevant true story during a presidential election should disqualify them. Unless the advice is used as a template in what not to do.
- muglug 5y ago
- renewiltord 5y agoInterested, but it seems a bit light on impl details. Presumably too early?
- yosito 5y agoThis rambling post from a web company I've never heard of touches on some interesting theories and attractive buzzwords, but it's overall main point is about as indecipherable as if the post had been autogenerated by GPT3 using the headline as the prompt. My unanswered questions are: who is Bluesky? What is their relationship with Twitter? Are they developing a tangible protocol that has concrete specifications, a roadmap, and path to adoption? Or is this just a rambling blog post about some ideas that could be applied to a social protocol?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- iamstupidsimple 5y agoI believe it's part of (or at least funded by) Twitter: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bluesky_(protocol) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bluesky_(protocol)
- wolverine876 5y agoIt is/was a project of Jack Dorsey, Twitter CEO https://www.cnbc.com/2019/12/11/twitter-ceo-jack-dorsey-announces-bluesky-social-media-standards-push.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/12/11/twitter-ceo-jack-dorsey-anno...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- whyrusleeping 5y agoHello Fellow Internet User, In general, it is your own responsibility to keep yourself informed when commenting on something. The World Wide Web makes this easy with something called a 'hyperlink', for example, the one at the top of the article you read that says 'blog': https://blueskyweb.xyz/blog https://blueskyweb.xyz/blog
- yosito 5y agoThe responsibility to communicate well does not fall on the reader. This blog post did not communicate well.
- steve76 5y ago
- wolverine876 5y agoFor those unaware, it is/was a project of Twitter's Jack Dorsey. You can find many news stories covering it from when it was announced. Here's one: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/12/11/twitter-ceo-jack-dorsey-announces-bluesky-social-media-standards-push.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/12/11/twitter-ceo-jack-dorsey-anno...
- rglullis 5y agoForgive my cynicism, but it's been two years already since bluesky was announced and all we see is the occasional update from what seems a research project. Nothing really tangible is released, no extension proposal to the existing protocols is made, not one single proof-of-concept that shows "look, protocol X can not do Y, so we implemented Z". Every update from them feels more and more like an elaborate PR piece. Just some hot air to keep the illusion that Jack really cares about decentralization.
- pfraze 5y agoTwo years were spent talking among projects in the community. You're seeing stuff now because we formed a company at the beginning of this year and started building. (We explain in this post why none of the existing projects were picked and why we decided to build new.) Backstory here: https://blueskyweb.xyz/blog/2-28-2022-how-it-started https://blueskyweb.xyz/blog/2-28-2022-how-it-started
- rglullis 5y agoNo, you do not really explain. "None of them fully met the goals" is not an explanation, it's an excuse. What are the goals missing? What is it from each of these protocols that is falling short? Can they be remedied or are there inherit limitations to all of them that warrants working on something completely new?
- Barrin92 5y agoThis early rather than focus on technical problems I would have liked to see the essential question addressed first, how Bluesky will deal with the issue that moved us from protocols to platforms to begin with. The reason the internet is now increasingly in vertically integrated platforms is governance. Companies can innovate quickly. The question any protocol driven approach must answer is how it is going to develop and push its protocol forward in the face of dynamic competition from proprietary systems. The reason why we're all now on Slack or Discord or Signal and Whatsapp rather than on IRC or Activity Pub social networks is because firms, that is to say top-down organizations can push features quickly. Decentralization comes at very high costs. If a protocol is too slow in offering more features what will naturally happen is that closed systems will come, fracture it and eat their lunch. This is exactly what already happened once. And given that it already happened, how that can be avoided ought to be answered first.
- jaredcwhite 5y agoTalking about IRC in particular, the reason I'm on Discord is: (a) UX far beyond anything I've seen with IRC (b) super easy for people to create new Discord "servers" (c) super easy to discover or link to Discord servers Talking about social microblogging/commenting (aka Twitter), the reasons I joined then later exited the ActivityPub "fediverse": (a) Twitter's discovery is massively better (b) My "identity" was not portable between instances (that's different from user on Network A interacting with user on Network B), also no easy way to link multiple instance identities If bluesky can solve all these identity/discovery/onboarding UX issues in the context of an open protocol, it'll be a massive step forward.
- rglullis 5y ago> My "identity" was not portable between instances (that's different from user on Network A interacting with user on Network B), also no easy way to link multiple instance identities That is by design. It's a federated system! Just like you don't need multiple phone numbers to talk with people in different networks, or different email addresses depending on the recipient, you don't need different identities to communicate with different servers. Unless you want to keep your identities separate, there is no point in having multiple accounts.
- hahamaster 5y agoSounds like Taligent, Pink and Longhorn all in one.
- victor_e 5y agoI believe platforms will always exist but imagine data will be more portable in the future. I think the focus should be on data. I propose the Newton Web Protocol. For each action that a user makes, an equal action is pushed back for the user to consume. When a user interacts with a website (comment, like, save, upload, etc.) the website pushes data/an event which can be consumed only by the author. When consumed the data/event could be processed: saved or replicated to other sites or the authors own site.