4 ms·
I don't believe in viral GPL based enforcement of free software and things like GPL being used as mechanism to keep out ZFS and things like that. But weak-copy
by panick21_ 5y ago
I don't believe in viral GPL based enforcement of free software and things like GPL being used as mechanism to keep out ZFS and things like that.
But weak-copy left and MIT style licenses are great and are winning.
Go back 10-20 years and we live in a much, much, much worse world in virtually every domain.
Not to mention open hardware, open FPGA, open chips and so on.
How many databases are still closed source today? How many compilers? How many programing languages?
Compare now to the 90s and its actually mind blowing how different everything is.
- ilovecaching 5y agoThere is a good talk by one of the authors of the X windows system as to why MIT for them was a mistake and how he'd wish they'd used the GPL. One could argue that a copycenter license is really just doing you doing the work of corporations for free, and when it comes time for them to contribute back to the hard work you've done, or to avoid fracturing the community by creating non-free addons, etc. I agree that there is a lot of open source software, but there is also a pattern of corporations taking what they can and then building their own proprietary walled gardens around it. Most normal people still interact with the world through non-free software, a lot of which spends time spying on them, which is one of the main points RMS makes about why source code should be a right.
- panick21_ 5y agoAnd GPL prevents that only partially. As GPL does nothing to prevent Amazon Cloud. We know that Amazon internal Linux has changes. Its only about distribution. And not sure how X history would be different. Yes, for a program that we know would turn universal eventually it might have been helpful. It also might not have ever been open source or whatever. And again, a weak copy left like the CDDL style license might have been even better. The MPL 2.0 explicitly allows other open source licenses as well. The MPL 2.0 is what I think is pretty idea for a lot of things.
- jrm4 5y agoSure, but the important question is: Would the weak licenses even exist in their current form if not for the visibility of the strong ones, or would "ownership creep" have likely eaten the weak ones, pushing them in a further proprietary direction? Hard to prove, of course, but I believe this is certain.