3 ms·
Precisely. Everyone adores a caring and benevolent dictator. The problem is that the sort of personality traits that inspire someone to pursue a position of pow
by kibwen 5y ago
Precisely. Everyone adores a caring and benevolent dictator. The problem is that the sort of personality traits that inspire someone to pursue a position of power make it overwhelmingly likely that your dictator will be malevolent rather than benevolent. There's a reason that examples of effective BDFLs arise from cases where the dictator was in place before the project became popular.
The other problem is the continuity of leadership. Despite its flaws, one of the strengths of democracy is that the code paths for the transition of power are explicit and regularly exercised. The only reason that anybody has any faith in any potential replacement for Torvalds is that, presumably, Torvalds will hand-pick his inevitable successor. But the successor's inevitable successor will have none of the same legitimacy, and by that time (be it decades from now) I expect the project to transition away from a BDFL model out of necessity.