2 ms·
That's true, but not a ding on Moorcock here. This usage to refer to right wing social policy is common on the activist left, and this is an interview in New S
by ajross 5y ago
That's true, but not a ding on Moorcock here. This usage to refer to right wing social policy is common on the activist left, and this is an interview in New Statesman. He's speaking his own dialect to his own people, and anyone familiar with that discourse is going to know what he means (that Tolkien in the modern world would be a friend to the bougies and not the downtrodden, clearly not that Tolkien was a fan of 1930's fascist regimes).
And... Moorcock is right as far as it goes. Tolkien revolutionized worldbuilding in fiction and inspired generations. But throughout the corpus the one theme that is conspicuously absent is "social progress". The only way to make things better in Middle Earth is to try to go back to the way things were, in vain attempts to recall the glories of Numenor, or Beleriand, or Valinor. No one fixes anything. No one improves anything. No one even tries, really. From the perspective of a modern reader, especially a leftist one, that's really quite jarring.
- coldtea 5y ago>(that Tolkien in the modern world would be a friend to the bougies and not the downtrodden, clearly not that Tolkien was a fan of 1930's fascist regimes). I know the dialect, but that's not some objective fact, just an interpretation from a particular political viewpoint. I'd say it's the reverse: Tolkien would be more of a friend to the downtrodden and their ideology, and not to the popular causes of the aspirational classes of the 10%. It's the downtrodden that's fashionable to talk down when you're in the modern "left" (as opposed to traditional left, who was all for working class people).
- ajross 5y agoAgain, you seem to be making a broader political point that I don't think is appropriate. Moorcock was talking about literature here. Even if you disagree with contemporary leftist thought, you'd agree that it's worth reading books dealing with the ideas, right? Same principle. Moorcock isn't saying "don't read LotR", he's pointing out that it's a thematically conservative trilogy.
- coldtea 5y ago>Moorcock isn't saying "don't read LotR", he's pointing out that it's a thematically conservative trilogy. I'm down with that, but "proto-fascist" is strong. Conservative != fascist. Many conservatives in fact fought the actual fascists...