6 ms·
> tyranny of the minority this is a trendy thing too, very often minorities who felt ignored, are now pushing to get more because of the tiranny of the majorit
by agumonkey 5y ago
> tyranny of the minority
this is a trendy thing too, very often minorities who felt ignored, are now pushing to get more because of the tiranny of the majority had flaws (but to me is mostly unavoidable due to the natural economies of scale it grants).
I don't know how one can design a social system where you balance both in the right way.
- q-big 5y ago> I don't know how one can design a social system where you balance both in the right way. The central problem is: how shall the "right way" in "both in the right way" even be defined?
- forgotmypw17 5y agoI think one possible solution is to create systems which are designed to fragment and split up from the beginning.
- hanselot 5y ago
- mwcampbell 5y ago> the tiranny of the majority had flaws (but to me is mostly unavoidable due to the natural economies of scale it grants). In a different context, this is a source of frustration for me as a (partially) blind person advocating accessibility for blind people. The world is designed around the assumption, correct for most people, that people have the high-bandwidth, low-latency sense of sight. And that does lead to the most effective interface for most people. That assumption is so thoroughly baked into everything that I sometimes think it might have been better if, through some kind of eugenics, I and people like me (blind from birth) had never been born at all, so the world could go on with that assumption (as it mostly does anyway) without leaving us out. I know eugenics is a taboo idea though, and it has its own problems.
- necovek 5y agoOne thing to keep in mind is that eyesight is a continuum between better than 20/20 to completely blind like you. That means that without going the only-the-perfect-survive route, there are always going to be issues with how the world operates. For any given human problem, it's probably rare that it's optimized for even half the population. Doesn't help you, being on the extreme of the eyesight problem, but the fact that we need to accommodate blind people also helps a bunch for people with vision issues and (commonly imperfect) correction. So while you can consider yourself to be in the small percentage of completely blind people, you can also consider yourself to be in the majority of people with vision issues. Should we have avoided all of them in this world? And that's wherein lies the issue with eugenics or any sort of artifical selection of our descendants: where is that line? And just judging by this single comment, you are at least capable of eloquent, reasonable discussion, which is probably untrue for at least half the population.
- scandox 5y agoI think parent poster is actually only partially blind
- mwcampbell 5y agoCorrect. Legally blind, meaning, for example, that I can't drive, but with enough sight to read text up close if it's large enough. Edit to add: I do increasingly depend on a screen reader, though not yet for my actual programming work. ETA 2: Sorry for the confusion in the original comment. I've become wary of terms like "visually impaired", because they wreak of over-sensitivity and political correctness. But there's also something to be said for accurately and clearly communicating the actual condition.
- andrepd 5y ago"Visually impaired" is a WHO technical term that encompasses visual acuity worse than 6/18.