6 ms·
> Few things have as strong of a humanizing effect. This, unfortunately, is EXACTLY what high pressure religions/cults/MLMs use to their advantage. I was a mo
by cogman10 5y ago
> Few things have as strong of a humanizing effect.
This, unfortunately, is EXACTLY what high pressure religions/cults/MLMs use to their advantage.
I was a mormon missionary and one of the things we were taught to look out for is things to humanize ourselves. Literally "If you see toys in the yard, ask them about their kids. Are they washing a car? Ask if you can help. Was there a death in the family? Talk to them about mormon heaven." etc.
The key, here, was all about conversion. You find an opening and then try and wedge yourself in (with the ultimate goal of getting a new convert, because you are "saving" them).
Other cults are certainly worse (NEVER go to a "private" meeting!), but it's something to realize. Cults are successful because they try and use genuine humanizing effects to bring in new members.
- borski 5y agoYou’re right, but it’s important not to throw the baby out with the bathwater. Many people drive cars. Some people kill others with theirs, sometimes intentionally. We should not then assume every person driving a car is on the warpath.
- tomcam 5y ago> We should not then assume every person driving a car is on the warpath. So you’ve never been to Boston
- pjmorris 5y agoOr South Florida. A looong time ago, after the business part of a phone interview, I was chatting with a recruiter who'd moved from Boston to South Florida and he asked me 'Is traffic ...different... here?' I gave him Dave Barry's explanation: "Everyone here drives according to the rules of their country of origin." Which reminds me of Sao Paulo. I've never seen more aggressive driving or been gladder that I wasn't driving than in Sao Paulo.
- psyc 5y agoFor me it was SE Asia. No rules of the road, only the rules of a school of fish.
- RHSeeger 5y agoTo be fair, at least some of that is the streets, not the drivers. I was in Boston a while back and I came to a crossroads. There was no stop sign, no light, nothing. I eventually just had to... go. I got to my hotel and I asked about it, and the concierge was like, "oh, its just like that". I asked how people are supposed to know to stop (or not to) and he replied, "you just know". It baffled me because _clearly_ you don't just know.. because I was there and I didn't know. What happens if two people just drive through the intersection at the same time. I get it that crossroads exist like this in the open nowhere. But... in a city? It was mind-boggling to me. Plus... the street layout in Boston was done by throwing pounds spaghetti at a wall and then trying to match the pattern that stuck.
- tomcam 5y agoAll true. That and even the kindliest Bostonian suddenly becomes a sociopath once behind the wheel.
- gumby 5y agoOn the other hand, the normally vicious Boston cops have true kindness by not enforcing any traffic laws. I remember a cop car pulling over to let us pass one time when my then gf drove the wrong way* down a one way street. And a friend was stopped when driving on the wrong side of mass ave (a divided road with a barrier). The cop stopped us, give us both a stern talking to, and then let us go on our merry way. * She is a physicist and her defense to me was “I was only driving in one direction”
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>I was in Boston a while back and I came to a crossroads. There was no stop sign, no light, nothing. I eventually just had to... go. I got to my hotel and I asked about it, and the concierge was like, "oh, its just like that". I asked how people are supposed to know to stop (or not to) and he replied, "you just know". It baffled me because _clearly_ you don't just know.. because I was there and I didn't know. What happens if two people just drive through the intersection at the same time. You got there without incident didn't you? Those sorts of intersections get treated like N-way rolling stops in practice. If there's someone who'll obviously be there first everyone adjusts speed so everyone can roll it without stopping. If multiple vehicles arrive at the same time negotiations ensue.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cogman10 5y agoI agree, I'm mostly advocating caution. Just like if you see a car swerving around in front of you, you might want to slow down and avoid. Sure, they might have just swatted a fly or something, but they also might be drunk. The issue is that cult interactions are crafted to specifically play on social norms. They are HIGHLY manipulative. I'm not saying that you should assume everyone is a manipulator, but you should at least have a little caution while talking to strangers. I had a college roommate that invited me out to pizza with him and another roommate. I accepted (what could be more normal) and he drove. It was a fucking "pesticide salesman" pitch. That was the last semester I roomed with them.
- ghufran_syed 5y agoI think most people have too much caution when talking to strangers for the first time. I think one should be careful when taking things further - maybe meet in public for the first few meetings, so you can easily make excuses and walk away if things turn weird. This also makes recruitment much more expensive for these kind of sales / recruitment tactics,
- snvzz 5y agoAsking because I couldn't find the answer after some cursory effort, and feel extremely out of the loop. What is a "pesticide salesman" pitch?
- RugnirViking 5y agoindeed, this hackernews page is one of the first page google results for that term. I'm curious!
- astura 5y agoThere's an MLM for everything, including Camel milk. Aptive Environmental looks to be the pesticide MLM.
- cogman10 5y agoIn my college, one of the more common MLM type things was getting recruited to travel to another state and do door to door sales of alarms and pesticides. With all the hallmark "You'll make a billion dollars!" types sketchiness. All structured as a standard MLM.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoThis easily shades into love-bombing, which is a standard recruitment technique. "Oh, you're so interesting." Etc. I deliberately went to a private meeting to see how all of this worked, and it was me and two recruiters with a huge picture of the cult leader. Super awkward. We asked each other a lot of questions. One of mine was "Are you sure you're not a cult?" "Oh no. We're definitely not a cult. Why would you think that? Ha ha. Oh dear. No." As cults go, I didn't get the impression they were very successful.
- dgivney 5y agoYou should have stood up like "Dammit, I'm looking to join a cult. Sorry for wasting your time."
- zabzonk 5y ago
- arrow7000 5y agoPeople don't choose the religion they are born into
- cogman10 5y agoBingo
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI expect people to have sufficient cognitive capacities by the time they are 18 to choose their religion. Even earlier if you know English and have access to the internet. Although financial dependence on one’s family could require putting on a show.
- derekp7 5y agoIt really doesn't work like that. As proof of the large barrier to entry, look at the number of people who follow the religion they were raised with. The rational decision is "These people I know and trust have this belief, so maybe they are right".
- lotsofpulp 5y agoA rational decision is still a choice, and I do not find it accurate to label it as "being born into". However, there is religion (assumptions held by someone in their mind) and religion (behavior that allows one to be part of a certain tribe). I can see the latter not being described as a choice if the person is dependent on the tribe.
- MaulingMonkey 5y ago> However, there is religion (assumptions held by someone in their mind) If your entire community holds the same assumptions (or at least publicly claims to), and you haven't been exposed to meaningful dissent and opposing viewpoints to challenge those assumptions, one is likely to uphold the same assumptions without ever having meaningfully questioned them, or ever having made any kind of active "decision" about said assumptions. To take a non-religious example, many of us grew up being taught and believing there were 9 planets in our solar system, and most of us accepted that without ever having meaningfully questioned the taxonomical decisions going into what exactly defines a "planet" versus smaller planetoids and how different Pluto might be from Ceres. We were born into a culture that seeded our assumptions, and we had no great need or reason to overturn them. This doesn't mean we can't break away from the culture we were born into given sufficient resources and/or reason (one can form dissenting opinions, one can move, ...) but it often explains default behavior, and what one might chose if they don't even realize they're making a choice, if only through inaction.
- ashtonkem 5y ago> Other cults are certainly worse (NEVER go to a "private" meeting!) I’ve had friends joke about going into the scientology temple in Hollywood as a joke. I always warn against it; cult recruiters are practiced and you are not.
- pyuser583 5y agoMy experience with cults is that they’re not effective, they simply focus on the minority who are open to their line. They even try to sound crazy, to discourage well-adapted people. Like a Nigerian scammer who deliberately uses bad grammar so the only responders are people with dementia. My experience with cults comes from being part of a large, mainstream church that had cooky and predatory groups operating at the margins of the congregation. They would target new members who had severe issues: drug abuse, mental illness, having been trafficked. I’m not sure if the Mormons have anything similar. I read about extreme fundamentalist Mormon groups, but they don’t seem to be recruiting mentally ill/drug addicted mainstream Mormons.