7 ms·
I've also had plenty of terrible experiences with strangers trying to talk to me. But I think it's wrong to build a policy from that: I've also had plenty of gr
by woodruffw 5y ago
I've also had plenty of terrible experiences with strangers trying to talk to me. But I think it's wrong to build a policy from that: I've also had plenty of great conversations with complete strangers, some of them in contexts where I'd be considered "captive" if I wasn't a willing participant (airplanes, trains, etc.).
IMO, serendipitous conversations are a key part of a healthy society. Few things have as strong of a humanizing effect.
- bavila 5y agoContext is definitely important. If I'm in a situation where I'm obviously just trying to get some work done in a coffee shop, I'd going to be very skeptical of a stranger who insists on striking up a conversation with me. It's just too pushy and frankly kind of creepy. However, I've also done some backpacking on the Appalachian Trail several years ago, and it's far more socially acceptable to start up a conversation with random people you meet along the way. It's understood that we're all strangers but we have a shared goal of hiking the trail, and what else are we going to do when we stop for the night other than chat a bit with the other people in the area? Had almost nothing but positive experiences speaking with random people while hiking, except for one nutcase (trail name was Mountain Lion) who was carrying a firearm and disclosed to me that he was kicked out of the military for mental health reasons (got to appreciate his honesty, though). I made sure to put as much distance between the two of us ASAP. Later found out he ran out of food, tried to steal from other people, and had to get airlifted out after getting injured. Good times.
- woodruffw 5y agoCertainly; context accounts for a lot. I wouldn't wish Mountain Lion on anyone :-) I think what it boils down to for me is this: the world is full of loons. If we don't allow ourselves to be open to spontaneous interactions, the average spontaneous interaction we have is more likely to be one involving a loon. Those memories also tend to be more salient because of their negativity, so we need to be intentional in remembering all of the lesser but positive experiences we've had with strangers.
- endgame 5y agoThis is why "charity muggers" infuriate me - they're poisoning the well for everyone else.
- walrus01 5y agoa lot of those are actually a 3rd party sales/marketing company that is paid a commission of something like 20-30% of each signup. If you pressure them enough they'll admit they they are not W2/T4 employess of the charity they're pushing. the vancouver area was plagued with the "because I'm a girl" charity muggers for years downtown
- version_five 5y agoHelsinki was lousy with them when I was there a few years ago. Between the train station and my hotel, a 10 minute walk at most, every intersection had them. I had one accost me and launch into her long spiel without me being able to stop her. When she finally paused to ask me something, I had to tell her I didn't speak Finnish. (Of course she spoke english but didn't press after that. And now that I think of it, and on-topic I had a similar thing happen with mormons pitching me in German in the Köln area. When they found out I couldn't understand them, they - as Americans - switched to English and we had an interesting conversation between strangers about why we were all there. They did not try to further sell me on the religion other than some very fleeting "if you're interested" as we parted. Overall it was actually interesting to meet them. Maybe it would have been different if I'd got the German pitch, we had a few really awkward approaches from these kind of religions people (evangelizers?) in university that were not as pleasant, I don't know what faith though. )
- cogman10 5y ago> Few things have as strong of a humanizing effect. This, unfortunately, is EXACTLY what high pressure religions/cults/MLMs use to their advantage. I was a mormon missionary and one of the things we were taught to look out for is things to humanize ourselves. Literally "If you see toys in the yard, ask them about their kids. Are they washing a car? Ask if you can help. Was there a death in the family? Talk to them about mormon heaven." etc. The key, here, was all about conversion. You find an opening and then try and wedge yourself in (with the ultimate goal of getting a new convert, because you are "saving" them). Other cults are certainly worse (NEVER go to a "private" meeting!), but it's something to realize. Cults are successful because they try and use genuine humanizing effects to bring in new members.
- borski 5y agoYou’re right, but it’s important not to throw the baby out with the bathwater. Many people drive cars. Some people kill others with theirs, sometimes intentionally. We should not then assume every person driving a car is on the warpath.
- tomcam 5y ago> We should not then assume every person driving a car is on the warpath. So you’ve never been to Boston
- pjmorris 5y agoOr South Florida. A looong time ago, after the business part of a phone interview, I was chatting with a recruiter who'd moved from Boston to South Florida and he asked me 'Is traffic ...different... here?' I gave him Dave Barry's explanation: "Everyone here drives according to the rules of their country of origin." Which reminds me of Sao Paulo. I've never seen more aggressive driving or been gladder that I wasn't driving than in Sao Paulo.
- psyc 5y agoFor me it was SE Asia. No rules of the road, only the rules of a school of fish.
- treeman79 5y agoI bought a nice truck in a bold color. Since then every few days total strangers come up to me and we start talking about trucks. Completely blows my mind, but they have all been super nice people.
- tomcam 5y agoWell now I have to know what color
- thomasjudge 5y agoHas to be red
- treeman79 5y agoLightning Blue
- tomcam 5y agoThe new Bronco? OK that’s pretty sweet. I grew up in low rider country so that doesn’t strike me as bold, but it is a great color.
- emerged 5y agoMy neighbor approached me so often, and/or yelled from across the street, about my 90s gas guzzler that one day I was so frustrated I waved him off shook my head and went inside. I just couldn’t deal with it again and it’s one of the rudest things I’ve probably ever done. I feel bad but it was an entirely unconscious reaction. I know almost nothing about cars and I really don’t care about them at all. He moved shortly after (hopefully unrelated lol), so nothing more ever came of that.
- arrow7000 5y agoI'm confused. What aspect of your car did he want to talk about?
- renewiltord 5y agoDefinitely one of my favourite things about living in America is the willingness of people to talk. Only London beats it in my opinion, despite so many people claiming that it is British to mind your own business.
- nicolas_t 5y agoFor me, it's Japan which surprises most people I tell that to, if you've ever watched midnight dinner, it's what happens in small dinners/izakayas, you go there by yourself and people will start talking to you.