7 ms·
Android and the false promises of openness
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- drivebyacct2 15y agoWhat does the ability to remove built in apps have to do with openness? Seriously, this is a piss poor reason to try to attack Android's openness. This is just a design choice on the part of people who ship phones. Be upset that manufacturers put their apps into /system/app and not /data/app, so that they would be removable. (Though most of the time, the space available to the ROM and user installable apps are partitioned and not shared). Open or not, removing data from the read only /system partition requires root. It's not a matter of "openness". Heck, the comments there do a plenty good job of describing what I've just detailed. Besides, rooting and custom firmwares are not illegal and most of the time will not stand up in court as warranty violations (at least surely not outside of the United States).
- MattBearman 15y agoIn the thread he says he's got a Nexus One. Unless I'm mistaken, Google Nexus phones come with a raw version of Android installed, with none of the bloatware that the manufacturers of carriers like to bake in. This means that Android itself is not allowing him to remove Facebook (or Twitter), and I'm inclined to agree that it goes against the 'open' label that Google like to put on android. Having said that, I completely agree that if you want a truly open phone, you can't expect a warranty as well, that would be having your cake and eating it.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoRight, but this is just a symptom of how the platform was designed. If you want "Facebook" and "Twitter" to come with the phone, it has to go in /system/app... and by virtue of again, Android's design, APKs are not removable from /system/app. If they were removable, bad things would be able to happen with low ability to recover without requiring a user download a 100MB file, name it specially and reboot their phone holding certain buttons down. I have no problem with addressing this as a design flaw, but it seems beyond unreasonable to use this as a way to attack Android's openness. The point remains, he can fork CM's repo right now, make /system/app user read/write-able and go on his marry way deleating whatever he likes. It's like attacking Ubuntu as being not open, because Gnome-screensaver doesn't let you tweak the screensaver settings (it was among the other dozen features simply removed in the last 3+ years)
- bodski 15y agoThe OP states further down that the issue they have is with the carrier: "I have to agree that my carrier is more to blame than Google or Android. After all, the facebook app isn't in the android source tree. It was introduced and locked in by my carrier. My grippe is more about Android being touted left and right as a the first Open mobile platform while when it reaches the end user it's been locked by the carrier. But indeed, my diatribe should have been more targeted to my carrier."
- huxley 15y agoI'm pretty sure the OP is wrong, Nexus One is built to Google's spec and if the carrier added an undeleteable Facebook app it is because Google gave it the go-ahead. If not, what is the point of buying the Nexus phones? It's Google's flagship stock Android, isn't it?
- MattBearman 15y agoFair enough, didn't realise you could get Nexus phones from a carrier, I though Google only sold them direct.
- yardie 15y agoHaving said that, I completely agree that if you want a truly open phone, you can't expect a warranty as well, that would be having your cake and eating it. Why not? I can order a server from Dell/HP/Lenovo with or without an OS and it's fully warrantied. The TSR won't say, "you installed OpenBSD and now one of your RAM chips is defective? Tough luck!" Exactly what is in the software that a wipe and restore won't be able to rule out a software problem?
- dredmorbius 15y agoWell, we could, say, look at the FSF's definition of free software: http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html - The freedom to run the program, for any purpose (freedom 0). - The freedom to study how the program works, and change it so it does your computing as you wish (freedom 1). Access to the source code is a precondition for this. - The freedom to redistribute copies so you can help your neighbor (freedom 2). - The freedom to distribute copies of your modified versions to others (freedom 3). By doing this you can give the whole community a chance to benefit from your changes. Access to the source code is a precondition for this. It's arguable that the ability to install/uninstall a program isn't direction mentioned among these freedoms, but the ability, say, to run the software deletion program for any purpose would fall under that cateogory, and Android fails in this regard. The Android platform as a whole is most certainly NOT FSF Free Software. There's some free software at the core. I consider my Android phone to be a proprietary product, and one I trust little with my privacy, confidentiality, and/or data integrity. Unfortunately, it's best-of-breed and "most free" of generally available smartphone software presently, though Meego (or whatever it's being called today) and the Nokia 900 series might be a superior option (I've got my eye on both).
- bozho 15y agoYou said it "I need to root my phone and thus void my warranty". If you void your warranty you are free to do whatever you like with your phone. If it was "truly open", you wouldn't have a warranty. It's always a balance - do you want something you have complete control over, including the possibility to break it, or you want limited control but be sure that even if it breaks, you get a new one? The platform itself is "open enough", but manufacturers and carriers are making a business out of it. And for the record, I think you can click "clear data", and also use some process monitor to kill your unwanted apps. My facebook app doesn't have these issues
- drieddust 15y agoI disagree. Warranty should be void if I am tempering with the hardware.Imagine laptop vendor doing the same if you install Linux on a Windows laptop. They may refuse to support the software issues but saying warranty is void because you have changed OS is ludicrous.
- starwed 15y agoSure, but this doesn't matter in practice. I have never heard of anyone with a physically broken device being refused service because they have rooted it. I imagine they want to be able to cover their ass in case some popular ROM starts causing problems. Their actual actions, as opposed to the what they are theoretically able to do because of the terms you agree to, are pretty reasonable.
- nuclear_eclipse 15y agoBut are you confusing OS with firmware? When you root your phone, you basically have to overwrite the firmware, eg, the recovery bootloader, to be able to flash a ROM. I'm pretty sure a laptop vendor would consider your warranty void if you decided to flash your BIOS with something other than an official update.
- drieddust 15y agoYour argument hold true if phone manufactures does not go out of the way preventing installation of custom ROM. Most of the manufactures design boot loader to specifically disallow installation of customs ROM.
- machrider 15y agoIt's not truly open but Android (as a platform) does seem to be moving in the right direction. I'm not an Android OS hacker, but as an outsider, my complaint would be that it is apparently very hard to get AOSP up and running on an off-the-shelf phone today. This is from my personal experience of trying several ROMs on my Galaxy S and finding that many are extremely unstable. It seems like the dev teams have to work very hard to make basic things like phone calls and the GPS work correctly. Even the process of installing a ROM and flashing different bootloaders when you get stuck in a boot loop, etc, just seems wrong. But it's early to be complaining. The OSS revolution on PC hardware didn't happen overnight. We now live in somewhat of a golden age where people can run 100% open software on their PCs, and in a lot of cases it also "Just works". I hope Android continues to mature in that direction such that, eventually, it will be a matter of selecting a distro and installing it on your phone (and getting exactly the behavior you want from your phone). Today you can run a custom ROM, but it is pretty hacky, involving trolling forums and downloading a few zipfiles and hoping they will unpack and run correctly. (And "rooting" your phone.) And it can go horribly wrong (I seem to have damaged the "download mode" on my phone the last time around, but fortunately I've ended up with a stable 2.2 system). In a couple years time, I'm hoping the landscape will look a little more like the Linux/PC world we have now. It may be that we'll have to stop hoping Google will be our benevolent dictator and form an independent Android OSS community, though.
- Tyrannosaurs 15y agoIs it moving in the right direction? This is an open source project that hasn't done a code release for the last few versions (covering almost a year) and is tightening the licensing agreements to exert control (and doing so in such a way that anyone who isn't a proper licensee will struggle to compete). Yes they've said that they'll open it up again once Ice Cream Sandwich is out but I'm unconvinced by a company who close off the source as and when it suits them. It feels closer to some sort of "shared source" model than open source. It might be better than the Apple iOS / Microsoft Windows Phone model (though I'm not 100% clear exactly how much better) but it seems to stop a long, long way short of the ideal. EDIT: Sorry, being a bit unclear in what I mean by shared source. I was trying to differentiate between projects than run in a open / collaborative way and those where they just publish the code after the event. I wasn't aware that shared source had already been coined to describe a particular model.
- sylvanaar 15y agoThis reminds me of Republican politics - while you were busy hating Apple (or gays in the case of Republicans) - they were busy with their real work - making deals that don't have your best interest in mind.
- biafra 15y agoAndroid is that much open that you can buy closed versions of it. Yeah, I know that sounds silly. If you really want the open Android you have to get a phone with an unlocked bootloader and compile AOSP for yourself. Then you can remove or add whatever you want.
- zobzu 15y agoBy reading the comments I figured the biggest issue with "open source" is that it is misunderstood, and terms are abused in various directions which have different meanings. Generally people use FOSS (Free Open Source Software) as the term to coin the meaning: "its open source, without compromises. It will never be closed, even for a while. AKA it's open source AND free as in freedom - yours - not the companies". Ends up in a BSD (pro for companies) vs GPL (pro for the users) fight usually. You'd think most would prefer GPL, but many of us actually work for companies and vote BSD (or similar) because it helps the hand that feed them. (I certainly vote GPL) The GPLv3 added some more depth to the understanding of FOSS - it's been criticized, also by M. Torvalds, who's getting most contributions from people working for said companies. The level of depth is simple: not only the software code must be available, possible to build and reproduce, but you must be able to do that on your device, that one which you own. It's all about power and control. They want to control you. Eg, have Facebook installed and potentially running even if you don't use it. That's control. That your warranty becomes void if you root the phone, that's for control too. They don't want you to be in control. That's a good part of what FOSS is about: ensure that you stay in control. And that's also what simple OSS (Open Source Software) does not provide. An I think that's important for our future, as software takes a big part of our lives.
- bergie 15y agoI think the question should be more about project governance, not about license details. Android may be open source by license, but it is not by process. http://bergie.iki.fi/blog/open_source-free_software-what_we_need_is_open_projects/ http://bergie.iki.fi/blog/open_source-free_software-what_we_... MeeGo had the potential to provide a better-governed alternative, but that was unfortunately squandered
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoRelated to the American model of phone purchasing, where phones are leveraged through contract costs. Kind of like leasing the phone. Other countries, you buy your phone, you lease your service. Owning your phone, you can do anything you like with it.
- thatjoshguy 15y agoAnd then there are hybrids, like paying the phone off over the life of the contract as an additional cost. Sometimes telcos (such as Telstra) will 'pitch in' and pay some of your repayments for you.
- danmaz74 15y agoExactly. I don't see how this is in any way related to Android being open or not...