3 ms·
Stallman's entire approach is "free === good, proprietary === bad". His comments on Steve and "fools" is basically saying that freedom means we should all be us
by stephenr 15y ago
Stallman's entire approach is "free === good, proprietary === bad". His comments on Steve and "fools" is basically saying that freedom means we should all be using what he claims to be good.
Stallman is no less a "dictator" than Steve ever was, he's just not successful at it.
- grey 15y agoI think you misunderstand. You're right that to him "free === good, proprietary === bad" and since his software (GNU) is one of the few platforms that really qualifies as "free" he encourages people to use it, however he's made it perfectly clear what it takes to qualify something as "free" and many many other independent developers have released software that meets this qualification. To consider Stallman a "dictator" is simply ludicrous, the entire point of his philosophy is that once software is released to the end user, that end user has almost all the rights to do anything they please with it, The only thing they can't do is take those rights away from others.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- kds 15y ago...he's just not successful at it. Could you specify the metrics by which Stallman is not successful (esp. compared to Jobs)? If you imply some kind of comparison involving Apple's revenues/market cap/corporate success - that's not quite right as an approach. Unless you compare such values with the overall economic effect of the GNU/FreeSoftware/OSS tools, compilers, whole Unix-like OS-es that have been freely available (also evolving during that time) for more than two decades. All this is something which empowered millions (companies, startups, individuals) and Stallman simply chose not to cash on commercial success because of his firm beliefs. I doubt Apple and Jobs would win at such a comparison. (I say this with all the respect for the great marketer and technology visionary that Jobs was.)
- stephenr 15y agoStallman doesn't just want to use Free software himself. He wants everyone everywhere to use free softwhere and nothing else, and even calls those who dare to use something proprietary "fools". So as I said - he is a dictator and wants everyone to do as HE sees fit, whereas Jobs was perfectly happy for people to use other platforms if they prefer - he just wanted the one he was offering to be the best it could be, and in many people's opinion, he succeeded. Jobs was called a dictator because he had very stringent control over Apple and the devices/software they create (both in terms of the design process, and to a lesser extent the users), but they never once said "hey if you don't use our software you're a fool". Stallman is a (failed) dictator because he thinks he has the right to tell other people what they should be doing, and should not be doing. Why he tells them or what he tells them is irrelevant. If he truly believed in freedom, he would be happy that Apple and all the other computer/phone manufacturers are all driving each other forward in terms of innovation, and that ultimately, that means MORE FREEDOM for the user - freedom to CHOOSE WHAT THEY WANT TO BUY. In Stallman's ideal world there is no Apple or Microsoft or any other company that sells products, and everyone uses Linux or BSD etc, and anyone who dares to think they can make something better and make money from it, is laughed at. That isn't freedom, that's an out of touch toe-jam eating nerds fantasy.