16 ms·
I predict a "Streaming Day of Reckoning" happening one day, where a critical mass of users suddenly loses access to a critical mass of content, because they bec
by ryandrake 5y ago
I predict a "Streaming Day of Reckoning" happening one day, where a critical mass of users suddenly loses access to a critical mass of content, because they became utterly dependent on streaming instead of physical media or local media storage. We occasionally read news of a handful of users losing access to a handful of content, and just shrug saying "Oh, well, streaming isn't perfect and this is growing pains." Maybe a user loses access to all their purchased Amazon movies because they got banned from the platform. "So sad," we say, as we continue to depend on streaming more and more. A niche streaming platform goes out of business and its small user base loses access to content. "Oh, well, there's still Netflix and Hulu," we say, as we keep switching to these platforms.
One day, a big one is going to go dark, and millions of people will suddenly lose access to the hundreds of movies they got used to accessing, and maybe we'll start waking up and looking for better alternative business models than streaming the same bytes over and over from centralized services.
- zapataband1 5y agocan we all please just go back to bitorrent
- recursive 5y agoWhat's stopping you? We're not all going, because I'm not going. For me, it's netflix and done. I don't have time or inclination to mess around with torrents.
- brimble 5y agoWe ought not allow production companies to own distribution channels (and vice-versa), nor long-term exclusive deals with distributors. That's how we solved this when similar issues arose with studio ownership of movie theaters—those restrictions just ended a little while ago, IIRC. But then, that was back when we, like, ever told companies "no" when it was clearly in the public interest. Not sure we can still do that. Ideally, a production company shouldn't give a shit where you watch their stuff, just that you do. That'd remove most of the friction that makes creation of a universal streaming UI difficult. It'd push distributors to compete on price and features, not exclusive access to content. All around a win for viewers, creating a healthier, more robust market. So, probably won't happen :-(
- noahtallen 5y agoI completely agree! I’ve been thinking about that a lot. I think not allowing exclusive licensing deals at all would be a huge win for consumers. Especially in streaming, but possibly in other areas too. I can’t think of a single reason it’s good for consumers — exclusive access to something on Netflix is ONLY good for Netflix. It’s advertised as good for me, but it’d be even better for me if other services also had it. Exclusive licensing is just a way for the entire streaming industry to avoid competition. Are Netflix and HBO really directly competing if you have to get both to watch the content you want? Sure, they’re competing for my attention with what I end up watching. But if I really want to watch something else, I’ll just get to it later. It’s not really either/or.
- ThatPlayer 5y agoWhile I agree with the separation, I don't know if exclusive access to content is as bad as you make it out to be. Exclusive deals aren't anything unique to streaming, and even the FTC will say it's a sign of a competitive market [0]. I think there's only so many ways that can compete on features, and price is going to be set by the licenser anyways, who are going to go with the one that pays the best regardless of exclusivity deals. [0] https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/competition-guidance/guide-antitrust-laws/single-firm-conduct/exclusive-supply-or https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/competition-guidance/guide-a...
- brimble 5y agoI think months or even a year is fine—longer-term deals, especially if tied to a whole catalog, start to look too much like ownership.
- vosper 5y ago> One day, a big one is going to go dark, and millions of people will suddenly lose access to the hundreds of movies they got used to accessing Probably one of the remaining streaming services will just buy the content at fire-sale prices, and people who want that stuff will have to switch services - which they had to do anyway, because their one went dark.
- dfxm12 5y agoI really don't understand this as a problem. Maybe for hardcores, who watch the same content over and over again and need to see things as soon as possible, in a particular quality, but those are the types who are likely to invest in physical media anyway (and really, that is the "better alternative" for people who are paranoid about online services going dark/removing access/whatever). There's just so much content on so many systems, all cheaper than buying one dvd per month that (some even free), that I just can't see anyone really being at a loss for how to entertain themselves in the case Netflix goes dark.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- julienb_sea 5y agoThe right to stream content is an asset which can and will change hands. If a streaming service is on the verge of shutdown, its streaming library can and will be sold off as part of shutdown proceedings and other streaming providers will happily step in. As such a "big one going dark" is going to be more of an annoyance than anything else.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- op00to 5y agoWhere have the mysterious bits to be streamed run off to in your scenario? Is it possible they still remain available to rightsholders, and will simply pass the streaming rights to the next “big one”?