3 ms·
4. How about an image search that... actually returns the URL of the raw image? Here's a dead simple use case that is just unnecessarily frustrating. As a user
by ryandrake 5y ago
4. How about an image search that... actually returns the URL of the raw image?
Here's a dead simple use case that is just unnecessarily frustrating. As a user, I want a high res picture of a buffalo. So:
a. I do an image search for "buffalo" and the results page contains thumbnails of buffalos.
b. I click the first result, it's tagged with "nationalgeographic.com" so it's probably gonna be good. Instead of the image, I get another page, but with a slightly bigger picture than a thumbnail. When you over over it, it says "3,072 x 3,072" but the image itself is clearly not that resolution.
c. So I click that image, and it opens a new goddamn tab of nationalgeographic.com's web site, with another picture, still not the promised 3,072 x 3,072! WTF!? When I try scrolling down to look for the raw image somewhere I'm hit with an E-mail signup-wall. Good grief!
d. Little did I know, if at step b. I instead right-clicked on the image and selected "Open Image in a new tab", I'd have gotten the image I was looking for. Thanks, Google, for hiding the 99.9% use case that people want to do.
The actual user experience should have been:
a. I do an image search for "buffalo" and the results page contains thumbnails of buffalos next to clickable .jpg links. The End.
- lupire 5y agoYes, everyone likes content better when they don't have to pay for it, all else equal. But content IP owners don't want to make content for free.
- Nextgrid 5y agoThey are welcome to disallow the Googlebot in their robots.txt.
- airstrike 5y agoWell, in the age of "creators" I'm sure there are countless of people who would be willing to post pictures of buffalo "for free" if they believed they had a chance of having their work actually make it to the top of the search results
- arecurrence 5y agoAlas, Getty sued that experience into oblivion https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2018/02/internet-rages-after-google-removes-view-image-button-bowing-to-getty/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2018/02/internet-rages-after...
- ryandrake 5y agoWow, I forgot about that--you're right. I guess I should rant at the lawyers instead. Thanks for the reminder!
- Nextgrid 5y agoWhy couldn't they litigate it? As far as I know it wasn't a court decision but a settlement, which means no legal precedent has been set and it wasn't determined whether their original behavior was actually illegal.
- LordDragonfang 5y agoIt's amazing to me that Pinterest hasn't been sued for this, despite having much more blatant examples of copyright infringement that don't link back to the source.
- superasn 5y agoYou can thank Getty images(1) for that :/ I personally think Getty and most stock image results are pure spam and google should have just ditched them altogether and kept the original search. Now google image search is also shit and full of stock photo spam: (1) https://9to5google.com/2018/02/09/google-images-features-getty-deal/ https://9to5google.com/2018/02/09/google-images-features-get...
- sam0x17 5y agoThere is actually a chrome extension that brings it back
- vikingerik 5y agoFor step d, why is that Google's fault? Your browser already has a means to view an individual image, why should Google reimplement something that a right-click can just already do?