3 ms·
The moment at which it seemed like the RISC people were really on to something important was the moment when the size and complexity of the x86 frontend was rea
by jeffbee 5y ago
The moment at which it seemed like the RISC people were really on to something important was the moment when the size and complexity of the x86 frontend was really quite large compared to the rest of the core. Now you can't even find the x86 decoder on a die shot, because it's irrelevant. The 512x512b FMA unit is like the size of Alaska and the decoder is the size of Monaco. So the advantages of RISC were overtaken by semiconductor physics for the most part.
- panick21_ 5y agoAgain, if you give 2 teams 50M to develop a new processor. One using x86 and the other using RISC-V I have not question in my mind what team would come out ahead.
- jeffbee 5y agoThat is exactly the ivory tower attitude that torpedoed all of the RISC workstation companies. Nobody, literally not one single customer cares how easy or hard it was to design and implement the CPU. They only care how much it costs and how fast it goes.
- snvzz 5y ago>They only care how much it costs and how fast it goes. Parent is telling you: At any given development cost, you'll end up with a faster CPU if you go RISC. This is why almost every new ISA to meet success in the last three decades has been RISC.
- panick21_ 5y agoIts the opposite of ivory tower, its simple analysis of complexity. To make the argument that CISC had anything to do with anything would be, what if in mid-95s Sun, SGI would have released their own CISC ISA. That would have been literally crazy. > Nobody, literally not one single customer cares how easy or hard it was to design and implement the CPU The companies who produce them care. > They only care how much it costs and how fast it goes. Yes and I explained why x86 won based on that logic so I don't know what you arguing.
- snvzz 5y ago>The 512x512b FMA unit is like the size of Alaska and the decoder is the size of Monaco. So the advantages of RISC were overtaken by semiconductor physics for the most part. There still is a hardware advantage (has nothing to do with sizes, everything to do with complexity), but let's ignore that. RISC being simpler doesn't just help the hardware. It also helps the software, the whole stack. Extra complexity needs strong justification. RISC-V takes that idea seriously, and this is why it already has the traction it does, and is going through exponential growth.
- jeffbee 5y agoRISC-V has many nice properties but it didn't exist 25 years ago so what does it have to do with why those companies and their objectively inferior CPUs disappeared?
- hedgehog 5y agoIt seems to be more about skill and budget of the development teams, and those are both getting bigger. I think a major underlying factor is the massive increase of transistor budgets relative to clock speed and latency to memory. That pulls every architecture down the path of big caches, speculation, specialized functional units, multiprocessors, etc, that add complexity dwarfing anything in the front end. If I was starting fresh the labor to do x86 would be a handicap but on the other hand Intel switching to RISC-V or whatever wouldn't do anything for them.