3 ms·
Trying to be both sell a seller of very high end computer products while also doing your own chips and graphics at the same time is quite the lift. And at the s
by panick21_ 5y ago
Trying to be both sell a seller of very high end computer products while also doing your own chips and graphics at the same time is quite the lift. And at the same time their market was massively attacked from the low end.
The area where companies could do all that and do it successfully kind of ended in the late 90s. IBM survived but nothing can kill them, I assume they suffered too.
What do you think, going back to your first day, if you were CEO could have been done?
I always thought for Sun OpenSource Solaris, embracing x86, being RedHat and eventually Cloud could have been the winning combination.
- oppositelock 5y agoI think some kind of discipline around releasing products in a timely way by cutting features would have done wonders. However, the kinds of computers SGI built were on the way out, so they couldn't have survived without moving in the direction that people wanted. Maybe it was a company whose time had come. SGI wasn't set up to compete with the likes of NVIDIA and Intel.
- panick21_ 5y agoWhy couldn't they compete with NVIDIA? Were the not just as big?
- oppositelock 5y agoEngineering culture. SGI was not pragmatic in building hardware, more of an outlet for brilliant engineers to ship experiments.
- jacquesm 5y agoI can see how that was your view if you came in on the tail end but it definitely wasn't always so. I've owned quite a few of them and if you had the workload they delivered - at a price. But for what they could do they would be 3 to 4 years ahead of the curve for a long time, and then in the space of a few short years it all went to pieces. Between NVIDIA and the incredible clock speed improvements on the x86 SGI was pretty much a walking zombie that did not manage to change course fast enough. But CPU, graphics pipeline, machine and software to go with it is an expensive game to play if the number of units is smaller than any of your competitors that have specialized. I'm grateful they had their day, fondly remember IRIX and have gotten many productive years out of SGI hardware, my career would definitely not have taken off the way it did without them, in fact the whole 'webcam/camarades.com/ww.com' saga would have never happened if the SGI Indy did not ship with a camera out of the box.
- gugagore 5y agoI wasn't familiar, so I searched and found your great account of the history! https://jacquesmattheij.com/story-behind-wwcom-camaradescom/ https://jacquesmattheij.com/story-behind-wwcom-camaradescom/
- jacquesm 5y agoFun times! Also frustrating but an excellent school and all is well that ends well.
- digisign 5y agoThe PC market grew bottom up to be 10x the size of the workstation market during the 90s. Even with thinner margins, eventually workstation makers couldn't compete any longer on R&D spend. The book The Innovator's Dilemma describes the process.
- digisign 5y ago^meant thinner margins of PC industry.
- rbanffy 5y ago> What do you think, going back to your first day, if you were CEO could have been done? Not quite sure. You correctly pointed out SGI (HP, Sun, everyone else in the workstation segment) was suffering with Windows NT eating it from below. To counter that, SGI would need something to compete in price. IRIX always had excellent multiprocessor support and, with transistors getting smaller, adding more CPUs could give it some breathing room without doing any microarchitectural changes. For visualization hardware the same also applies - more dumb hardware with wider buses on a smaller node cost about the same while delivering better performance. To survive, they needed to offer something that's different enough from Windows NT boxes (on x86, MIPS and Alpha back then) while maintaining a better cost/benefit (and compatibility with software already created). I'd focus in low-end entry-level systems that could compete with the puny x86's by way of superior hardware-software integration. The kind of what Apple does, when you open the M1-based Air and it's out of hibernation before the lid is fully opened. > I always thought for Sun OpenSource Solaris, embracing x86, being RedHat and eventually Cloud could have been the winning combination. I think embracing x86 was a huge mistake by Sun - it helped legitimize it as a server platform. OpenSolaris was a step in the right direction, however, but their entry level systems were all x86 and, if you are building on x86, why would you want to deploy on much more expensive SPARC hardware? Sun never even tried to make a workstation based on Niagara (first gen would suck, second gen not so much), and OpenSolaris was too little, too late - by then the ship had sailed and technical workstations were all x86 boxes running Linux.
- panick21_ 5y ago> IRIX always had excellent multiprocessor support and, with transistors getting smaller, adding more CPUs could give it some breathing room without doing any microarchitectural changes. That kind of exactly what Sun did and likely gave them legs. This might not have made it out of the 90s otherwise. > I think embracing x86 was a huge mistake by Sun - it helped legitimize it as a server platform. x86 was simple better on performance. I think it would have happened anyway. > OpenSolaris was a step in the right direction, however, but their entry level systems were all x86 and, if you are building on x86, why would you want to deploy on much more expensive SPARC hardware? That's why I am saying they should have dropped Sparc already in the very early 2000s. They waste so much money on machines that were casually owned by x86.