2 ms·
Hmm. I think you're missing something important. Yes, you're absolutely right that the sound of a particular musician is shaped by their musical and social coll
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
Hmm. I think you're missing something important. Yes, you're absolutely right that the sound of a particular musician is shaped by their musical and social collaborations and history. Nobody could seriously question this.
However, when someone wants to hire Gavin right now, it's almost always because they want "the Gavin sound" (whatever they conceive that to be). Although a musician's sound is to some extent always evolving, after 10-20 years of playing, it's fairly well formed, and evolving much more slowly and more subtly. Their musical and social history is "baked in", so to speak.
So, you train up your overcooked cross-correlation analysis system on the drum performances of Gavin Harrison, and just like GPT-3 "responding" to text prompts, I think there's a pretty good chance it will "respond" to your musical prompts in a style very similar to Mr. Harrison. However, it will sound nothing like Mr. Collins (except to whatever extent Mr. Harrison already did, which is ... not so much).
> So the idea that ML will give you 20% this and 50% that is a non-starter.
That was specifically what I said. Even so, I think there's some possible artistic intrigue that might come from some sort of "cross-breeding" between two systems trained on two different drum performance sets.
Good to come across someone else who at least knows that Phil Collins was an amazing drummer and not just the only other person besides McCartney & Jackson to sell a million records inside and outside a band. Still, Chester Thompson, seriously :)