4 ms·
Most of what I remember about 90s RISC workstations is how unbelievably slow they were. On an SGI Octane in 1998 was giving integer performance about the same a
by jeffbee 5y ago
Most of what I remember about 90s RISC workstations is how unbelievably slow they were. On an SGI Octane in 1998 was giving integer performance about the same as 1996-released Pentium Pros. And that's why RISC died: not because it was cheaper but because it was both cheaper and faster. Sometimes dramatically faster. The idea that RISC was somehow elegant turned out to be a myth. The complexity of x86 mattered less as cores grew in size and sophistication, but the code compression properties of CISC continued to benefit x86.
- buescher 5y agoIt depends. Before peecee memory architectures got gud in the early oughts, the Octanes were sufficiently better for big finite element codes than Intel based machines that you'd still see them used for that. But it didn't last, and you're right that the writing was on the wall already in the mid nineties. I got a Pentium 90 running Slackware running some less demanding scientific code faster than a pretty loaded Indigo2 in that era.
- anthk 5y ago>I got a Pentium 90 running Slackware running some less demanding scientific code faster than a pretty loaded Indigo2 in that era. Well, FVWM and URxvt were lighter than MWM and Irix' setup for Winterm.
- panick21_ 5y agoRISC is better if you have finite money and want to build a chip. The simple reality is that Intel had the Wintel monopoly and they had gigantic volume and absurd amounts of money to invest. If you compare the size of teams working on SPARC to what Intel invested its totally clear why they ended up winning. > The idea that RISC was somehow elegant turned out to be a myth. No, it didn't. The reality is a bunch of literal students made a processor that outperformed industry cores. Imagine today if a university said 'we made a chip that is faster then i9'. The early RISC processors with pretty small amount of work very incredibly competitive. So yes, its was actually amazing and revolutionary and totally changed computing forever. That this advantage would magically mean 'RISC will be the best thing ever for the rest of history' is pretty crazy demand to make for it to be called revolution. > code compression properties of CISC continued to benefit x86. Not actually that much, code density of x86 for 64 bit systems isn't all that amazing. Its certainty not why they won.
- jeffbee 5y agoThe moment at which it seemed like the RISC people were really on to something important was the moment when the size and complexity of the x86 frontend was really quite large compared to the rest of the core. Now you can't even find the x86 decoder on a die shot, because it's irrelevant. The 512x512b FMA unit is like the size of Alaska and the decoder is the size of Monaco. So the advantages of RISC were overtaken by semiconductor physics for the most part.
- panick21_ 5y agoAgain, if you give 2 teams 50M to develop a new processor. One using x86 and the other using RISC-V I have not question in my mind what team would come out ahead.
- jeffbee 5y agoThat is exactly the ivory tower attitude that torpedoed all of the RISC workstation companies. Nobody, literally not one single customer cares how easy or hard it was to design and implement the CPU. They only care how much it costs and how fast it goes.
- snvzz 5y ago>They only care how much it costs and how fast it goes. Parent is telling you: At any given development cost, you'll end up with a faster CPU if you go RISC. This is why almost every new ISA to meet success in the last three decades has been RISC.
- panick21_ 5y agoIts the opposite of ivory tower, its simple analysis of complexity. To make the argument that CISC had anything to do with anything would be, what if in mid-95s Sun, SGI would have released their own CISC ISA. That would have been literally crazy. > Nobody, literally not one single customer cares how easy or hard it was to design and implement the CPU The companies who produce them care. > They only care how much it costs and how fast it goes. Yes and I explained why x86 won based on that logic so I don't know what you arguing.
- snvzz 5y ago>The idea that RISC was somehow elegant turned out to be a myth. Citation needed. Still, if you're thinking about Intel success, I can tell you there's two factors for it: IBM PC Clones and Intel's monopoly on advanced fab nodes. These were enough to overcompensated for CISC being trash. >the code compression properties of CISC continued to benefit x86. x86 had good code density. AMD64 (x86-64) has really bad code density, dramatically worse than RV64GC.
- mst 5y agoThe expense of fab node transitions back when every chip manufacturer built their own fabs seems to've contributed significantly to the demise of a fair few architectures over the years.