9 ms·
'Freeze-thaw battery' stores electricity long-term for seasonal release
- hermanb 5y agoOriginal article is a good read too: https://www.cell.com/cell-reports-physical-science/pdf/S2666-3864(22)00091-1.pdf https://www.cell.com/cell-reports-physical-science/pdf/S2666...
- lbriner 5y agoThis is pretty sweet! There isn't enough information about larger/heavier but greener battery technology that would be suitable for grid/home storage without the environmental costs associated with the rare earth stuff needed for transportation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ema 5y agoJust realized that with a battery intended for seasonal storage you only get one cycle per year so for the same ROI as a battery that cycles weekly or daily it has to be much cheaper per kwh of capacity. OTOH it only needs to last for like 50 cycles.
- maxerickson 5y agoI wonder what the napkin math is vs something like methane synthesis.
- telchar 5y agoI think you’re on to something with that. With so few round trip conversions compared to something that is charged/discharged frequently, the conversion efficiency doesn’t matter as much compared to the cost of storage. For a given kwh of storage that is round-tripped daily, a 1% loss of efficiency loses 3.65kwh per year. For a kWh of storage that is round-tripped once per year, you only lose 0.01kwh. At 70% conversion efficiency the yearly storage still loses only 1/10 the energy as a daily system at 99%.
- cupofpython 5y agoI like to imagine a system with the different geothermal-like technologies working together in maybe a layered like structure. Extracting from the winter / summer cycle, the day / night cycle, and the consistent deep ground / surface air temp differential. Granted day / night might not have enough variation to take advantage of in a lot of places - but surely some cool tech has come out of desert areas right?
- jdmichal 5y agoArid locations already enjoy much cheaper cooling via swamp coolers over heat pumps. They're just enough to keep it bearable during the day, then the night comes and clears out all the latent heat.
- seltzered_ 5y ago"The freeze-thaw phenomenon is possible because the battery’s electrolyte is molten salt - a molecular cousin of ordinary table salt. The material is liquid at higher temperatures but solid at room temperature. The freeze-thaw battery was shown to retain 92 per cent of its capacity over 12 weeks." Any relation between this and 'sodium-ion' battery companies like the recently acquired Faradion? (see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2PmRT3akGk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2PmRT3akGk )
- maxerickson 5y agoThe electrolyte is sodium aluminum and chlorine, which sounds pretty different than sodium-ion. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2666386422000911 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S266638642... The PNNL article is somewhat better than the current link. https://www.pnnl.gov/news-media/freeze-thaw-battery-adept-preserving-its-energy https://www.pnnl.gov/news-media/freeze-thaw-battery-adept-pr...
- cupofpython 5y agomolten salt is a form of long term energy storage being used by some companies. One example is below https://www.maltainc.com/our-solution https://www.maltainc.com/our-solution Some alternative methods and related companies: https://www.greenbiz.com/article/big-money-flows-long-duration-energy-storage https://www.greenbiz.com/article/big-money-flows-long-durati...
- phh 5y agoIt doesn't sound like the improvement of cost is enough the justify using it only for few cycles a year as the title says rather than every other day. That said, I see nothing in this article saying why it would be limited to seasonal release, I'm guessing it just has a lower self-discharge. The title made me thought of an idea my father had, for which I'm still totally ambivalent: Freeze water in the cellar (speaking of like 30m^3) using thermal pomp during winter to heat house and when electricity costs little, and use that ice in summer to cool down the house. I didn't run the numbers, but I'd guess that if it was even remotely not a pure energy loss some other people would have already proposed such things.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThere's a few large building air conditioning units that do exactly this. Ice Bear was one brand name I think.
- mabbo 5y ago> Freeze water in the cellar (speaking of like 30m^3) using thermal pomp during winter to heat house and when electricity costs little, and use that ice in summer to cool down the house. Unless I misunderstood, the Toronto Zoo has or had such a system setup for one or more of the food pavilions. What's interesting about this is that the storage grows with the volume (n^3), but the heat/cold loss grows with the surface area (n^2). So you're ability to 'store cold' gets better as you get bigger. Just the same, you could also use it backwards in the winter time. On hot, sunny days at the end of the summer, warm up the water stored.
- bombcar 5y agoThe cube/square law also applies in the opposite direction, this is why it takes longer for lakes to freeze and why the Great Lakes never do. I believe at least one university on the Great Lakes does heating and cooling with pipes deep under the lake.
- frosted-flakes 5y agoThe Great Lakes do occasionally freeze over significantly, though never completely. 2013-2014 was one such winter, when ice coverage reached 92% across all five lakes. That's quite unusual though. And the city of Toronto uses lake water for cooling. Heat from a downtown cooling loop is dumped into the city's drinking water supply, bringing the temperature up to around 13° from 6° (if I remember correctly).
- gwbas1c 5y ago> The battery’s theoretical energy density is 260 watt-hours per kilogram Makes me wonder how big a battery would need to be to handle all of the overwinter energy demands of some densely-populated US states.
- KaiserPro 5y agoMassive. But I don't think thats the point of this. I imagine you'd pair this with an energy source(say solar), so that you are able to smooth out/absorb excess energy and release when its needed. You could use it as an energy supply of last resort.
- mfringel 5y agoJust to put some numbers around that... Density of ice at 0 degC is 0.92 kg/L. So, 1 kg of ice =~ 1087 cubic centimeters of space, or a cube ~4.25 inches on a side. Rounding that down to 4 inches for the moment, you get 27 of those per cubic foot, or (260 Wh * 27) = 7.02 kWh, and then round that down to give the extra quarter-inch back, you get ~6.5 kWh/ft3 theoretical capacity. A typical household in the US uses 10,715 kWh/year[0], so (10715/6.5) = 1648.46 ft3 for a household's worth of freeze-thaw battery storage, or a cube 11.81 feet on a side. Yes, of course it's more complicated than that, but the scale is pretty interesting. --- [0] https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=97&t=3 https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=97&t=3
- KennyBlanken 5y agoIron flow batteries already exist commercially, are even more non-toxic/safe, and they don't require heating up (and keeping hot, while using) the battery. https://essinc.com/iron-flow-chemistry/ https://essinc.com/iron-flow-chemistry/ The utility industry isn't really that interested in storing power for an entire season. Very little ROI compared to a system that allows them to balance minute-to-minute or day/night...or transmission infrastructure improvements. Got excess generating capacity? Send it somewhere that doesn't. I hope that some day in the near future we see home-scale or neighborhood-scale iron flow battery systems so that homeowners, apartment buildings, and small neighborhoods can go off-grid.
- pjc50 5y agoI've never really seen the advantage in going off grid per se, since it increases the amount of wasted capacity in both generation and storage, and running a few wires is cheap enough in urban environments. The most efficient arrangement might be a global grid.
- projektfu 5y agoI am not off grid, but the thing that would draw me to it is as an individual sustainability goal. Perhaps it would be more expensive to initially set up and run, but it should be sustainable for 20-40 years. There is the side benefit of reducing the demand on energy to acheive this sustainably. Spending less on technology and energy means working less. In other words, we pay in our own time for the time technology saves us. To quote Thoreau: 'One says to me, “I wonder that you do not lay up money; you love to travel; you might take the cars and go to Fitchburg to-day and see the country.” But I am wiser than that. I have learned that the swiftest traveller is he that goes afoot. I say to my friend, Suppose we try who will get there first. The distance is thirty miles; the fare ninety cents. That is almost a day’s wages. I remember when wages were sixty cents a day for laborers on this very road. Well, I start now on foot, and get there before night; I have travelled at that rate by the week together. You will in the mean while have earned your fare, and arrive there some time to-morrow, or possibly this evening, if you are lucky enough to get a job in season. Instead of going to Fitchburg, you will be working here the greater part of the day. And so, if the railroad reached round the world, I think that I should keep ahead of you; and as for seeing the country and getting experience of that kind, I should have to cut your acquaintance altogether.' Walden, chapter 1, Economy.
- a9h74j 5y agoTangent, but in the seasonal storage context. Apparently, according to a reported simulation, if you (1) take a ca 15m x 15m house thermally in contact with the ground, (2) insulate the ground outside to a radius of ca 40m, and (3) heat the interior to say 25C, then (4) evenually (50years?) the ground itself under the house will come up to a steady temperature consistent with that. Even if the simulation was correct, I can only see this being sustainable with solar gain being used for heating, but it makes for an interesting long-term-oriented picture. One imaginable scale of application could be for a cluster of houses in a larger agricultural setting.
- gnorme 5y agoI'd love to read more about this simulation, have any links?
- a9h74j 5y agoI am unable to find a link, and IIRC this was reported 10 years ago or so. I recall an attribution to German designers or architects. I cannot remember where exactly it was reported, but I remember it as moderately plausible reporting, although not in a journal. A quick estimate with soil: Take a specific gravity of 2.7 gm/cm^3, a specific heat of 0.2 cal/gm-K, and 1 cal ~ 4.2J ~ 4.2 W-sec. For a cube 25 m (2500cm) on a side, if I am not mistaken this suggests a thermal inertia of about 3.5E10 W-sec/K. Now take a thermal conductivy of 1 W/m-K. For a slab of 25m x 25m, also with a thickness of 25m, we get a net conductivity of 25 W/K . Then 3.5E10 W-sec/K divided by 25 W/K gives 1.4E9 sec . Given 3E7 sec/year, that suggests about 47 years. Aka a 50 year time scale. Of course this assumes a low water table.
- snewman 5y agoGradual heating of the ground is definitely a thing; over the decades, certain London Tube lines have drifted from pleasantly cool to sweltering: https://www.wired.co.uk/article/central-line-temperature-london-weather-heatwave https://www.wired.co.uk/article/central-line-temperature-lon...
- 5y ago
- Gasp0de 5y agoThis doesn't seem cost efficient at all, my (medium sized) house in Germany consumes about 3000kWh of electricity during winter. This does not include heating, which consumes another 15.000kWh (of heat energy from oil, so around 5000kWh electrical energy with a heat pump). If I were to use this battery I would need to get 3000(8000)kWh of energy storage at 23$ per kWh which would amount to 69000(184000)$. There are better hydrogen-based solutions for that cost. Also, did I read correctly that I have to keep the battery heated to 180°C during discharge? This is going to waste a lot of energy in winter.
- gwbas1c 5y agoGosh, it's still coming out of academia. It takes awhile before these kinds of things are economically viable.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 5y agoThe economics is not great as described, but I wouldn't see this at being an individual level solution. The larger it is, the easier it is to insulate.
- awestroke 5y agoYou heat you house with oil? I thought Germany was environmentally conscious
- Gasp0de 5y agoUnfortunately, Germany has been ruled by a conservative party for the last 16 years and they did everything in their power to sabotage renewable energy so that lignite mining could stay longer. However, heating in Germany is a difficult problem to solve with renewable energy: You need lots of power in winter, when there is (close to) no power from solar. One solution would be excessive wind power and heat pumps that can be controlled remotely by the power grid operators.
- coryrc 5y ago
- jessriedel 5y agoFor more on the general problem of storing thermal (rather than electrical) energy on a seasonal basis see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasonal_thermal_energy_storage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasonal_thermal_energy_storag... I was especially surprised to learn that serious attempts at storing heat in soil and rock have been made https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasonal_thermal_energy_storage#Underground_thermal_energy_storage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seasonal_thermal_energy_storag... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drake_Landing_Solar_Community https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drake_Landing_Solar_Community which in the winter is able recover >40% of the energy stored in the ground through boreholes in the summer ("BTES Efficiency") https://www.dlsc.ca/reports/swc2017-0033-Mesquita.pdf https://www.dlsc.ca/reports/swc2017-0033-Mesquita.pdf
- nikanj 5y agoFurthermore, we have a real problem with the soil storing heat: https://citymonitor.ai/transport/londons-tube-has-been-running-so-long-its-literally-raising-temperature-earth-around-it https://citymonitor.ai/transport/londons-tube-has-been-runni...
- alexchamberlain 5y agoStupid question: can we harness this 100 year old heat to power something today?
- thescriptkiddie 5y agoYes https://www.newcivilengineer.com/innovative-thinking/harnessing-heat-from-the-tube-11-05-2020/ https://www.newcivilengineer.com/innovative-thinking/harness...
- vikingerik 5y agoYou can't exactly harness heat; what can be harnessed is a temperature differential, to convert into some form of mechanical motion or electrical potential. You'd need some apparatus that connects the hot mass and some cold sink with thermocouples. Whether that's possible or feasible on the scale of the London Tube, I don't know. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermoelectric_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermoelectric_effect Instead of that, probably a more feasible way to make use of heat is just as heat, by some way of circulating it into buildings in the winter. One interesting angle of looking at this would be that it's really an artificially created geothermal source.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoSeasonal storage and thermal batteries are pretty easy and cheap to construct. The materials tend to be cheap commodities. All you need is space to construct them and a way to produce the heat you use to charge them. For example, I know of an experimental setup in the Netherlands called CESAR (https://materialdistrict.com/article/battery-natural-stone/ https://materialdistrict.com/article/battery-natural-stone/) that uses basalt rock. The basalt is heated up using solar energy in the summer. It is stored in an a metal box insulated with wool that apparently retains heat for months/years. Long enough to last the winter. You 'discharge' by pumping cold water through it. Warm water comes out. Very simple. It has been running for a few years and it seems to be cheap and work as advertised. Relative to burning gas, this looks like a nice idea. Converting heat to electricity is more tricky and the efficiencies tend to be not great. Of course if the storage is cheap enough that might not be that big of a deal. Efficiencies are also a challenge with geothermal energy. But it's a great solution for heating buildings. This particular solution seems to work around this using molten salt which allows for a relatively large temperature gradient. But without having to drill kilometers into the earth's crust. Probably over time, cost will decide which solutions end up getting used where and how. A good insight here is that different storage solutions serve very different purposes. You don't use lithium ion for seasonal storage. It's way too expensive for that. But it's great for short term grid balancing needs and seems to be popular for that. Vice versa, thermal mass would be probably bad for balancing the grid it's great for storing lots of energy that you use up slowly during the winter. It's a tradeoff between how much energy you need stored, how much space you have for storing it, and how quickly you want to charge/discharge. It's telling a lot that a relatively expensive solution like lithium ion batteries are actually cost competitive with things like gas peaker plants. We can do probably do better long term. There is no shortage of good & already validated ideas in this space. All we need is good old engineering and manufacturing to prove products in the market at scale.
- mlatu 5y agothe article is about an _electrical_ battery that is seasonally heated up for usage and cooled down for the long term storage of the charge contained in it... i had only heard of molten salt batteries which need to stay hot long term, so they are heavily insulated maybe this article is talking about a primary battery (i.e. electrically not rechargable), which would make more sense
- credit_guy 5y agoSorry to be a killjoy, but $6/kwh is at least 20x too expensive. In 2021, the average price of electricity in the US was 14 cents/kwh. Assuming you charge with free electricity, your charge-discharge efficiency is 100%, there is no capacity loss over the years, and your cost of capital is zero, you need more than 40 years to break even at that price. All the 4 assumptions above and a few others (zero installation and maintenance cost, zero insurance, zero cost of disposal) are super unrealistic.
- AtlasBarfed 5y ago"Exploring the use of Iron" "Limited by Nickel" "Limited by Nickel": This is just lithium ion battery storage, it is plainly obvious. "Exploring the use of Iron": using LFP (which will be 200-230 wh/kg in production later this year) "Added some sulphur": great, but you're wayyyy behind the current state of the art research in Li-S. That cost is appropriate for maybe a day or two of storage. Months between seasons? That's ridiculous, even if we had a dirt-cheap 200 wh/kg sodium ion battery which COULD probably hit 6$/kg, unlike their unnamed/unspecified techs they are "looking into". Likely it is since every other battery buzzword was notched in this article. The use case, providing more energy in the summer, is covered with solar + couple day grid storage and existing nuclear or gas turbine for load leveling. What we need is to install as much wind and solar as possible to immediately eliminate coal, then add storage and more wind/solar as needed to start eating away at gas turbine. Nuclear should stick around for long-term load levelling until batteries become dirt dirt dirt cheap. This article is so poorly written that it might as well be unintentional FUD.
- mechagodzilla 5y agoI think you misunderstood the article - they're talking about the capacity of the battery in terms of kilowatt-hours, not its cost relative to round-trip efficiency. If the cost were $6/kwh, you could build a 100kwh battery for $600, and charge/discharge that many times. I think this is supposed to be interesting both for its relatively cheap materials (and useful level of energy density), and its ability to be 'frozen' in a room-temperature charged state for long periods of time without much loss of charge.
- wppick 5y agoIs there any examples of using something like a server farm to heat a building in the winter? Removing heat from a server farm through heat exchange with a cold building seems like an efficient combination of two interests (building needs heat, servers need to get rid of heat). Of course this becomes a problem in the summer months...
- wongarsu 5y agoStockholm, Sweden has an open district heating network: buildings can not only buy heat from it for heating, like a normal district heating network, they can also sell surplus heat to the network. At least two data centers (Bahnhof Thule and Bahnhof Pionen) sell heat from their heat exchangers to the network. https://celsiuscity.eu/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Waste-heat-from-data-centres.pdf https://celsiuscity.eu/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Waste-heat... pages 7-9
- grenoire 5y agoIn Amsterdam, the botanical gardens and Hermitage Amsterdam exchange heat in that sort of mutually beneficial way, https://www.cultureelerfgoed.nl/onderwerpen/praktijkvoorbeelden/overzicht-praktijkvoorbeelden/hermitage-en-hortus-delen-warmte-koudeopslag https://www.cultureelerfgoed.nl/onderwerpen/praktijkvoorbeel....
- uomo 5y agoOne of Amazon’s buildings in Seattle (Doppler) uses a data center next door to reduce their overall heating costs during the winter. Source: https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/sustainability/the-super-efficient-heat-source-hidden-below-amazons-seattle-headquarters https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/sustainability/the-super-ef...
- Quindecillion 5y agoThis is actually one of the use cases that Satoshi Nakamoto spoke about in regards to Bitcoin mining. The purpose built machines for mining (ASICs) turn electrical energy into heat through performing hashes. If you need electrical heating there's functionally no difference between turning a regular heater on or turning on an ASIC. The benefit of turning an ASIC on instead is you can recoup some of the cost of expending the electricity.
- pfdietz 5y agoThe issue with seasonal storage is that efficiency is much less important than capital cost. The cost of inefficiency is proportional to the number of charge/discharge cycles, the capital cost is not. So, it makes sense to look at systems like ones using hydrogen, since hydrogen can be stored underground as a compressed gas at a storage capacity cost of $1/kWh. Minimizing that capacity cost is crucial. Sure, the round trip efficiency will be poor (maybe 40%?) but as argued above that doesn't matter much.
- pfdietz 5y agoPrimary batteries based on molten salts ("reserve batteries") have been standard in military applications since just after WW2. They are ideal for munitions (fuzes, missiles) that need long storage life but don't need recharging.