3 ms·
You seem to be arguing against a view that USans invented everything about internetworking, but that's not a view I hold. I know lots of people from lots of pl
by kragen 5y ago
You seem to be arguing against a view that USans invented everything about internetworking, but that's not a view I hold. I know lots of people from lots of places did pioneering internetworking research! What I was saying is that the US is where the internet got deployed. Surely you are correct that without ARPANET someone still would have built an internet, and eventually it would have become worldwide. But what I'm pointing out is the contingent political facts that resulted in it happening in our timeline in the US rather than, for example, the USSR, where access to photocopiers was still tightly controlled.
I don't think "everything should be a market" is orthogonal to liberalism. At a large enough social scale, liberalism always produces markets unless warfare erupts; strong restrictions on commerce are necessary to prevent markets from arising among groups much larger than Dunbar's number.
I agree with you about Minitel; in fact, monopoly for-profit providers like CompuServe and Tymnet imposed the same kinds of restrictions on innovation that prevented the WWW from arising on their networks: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30916796 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30916796
- peoplefromibiza 5y ago> What I was saying is that the US is where the internet got deployed The "Internet" as we know it was deployed as a research network in 1987, it was already connected to Europe research centers in 1988. That's why WWW was born at CERN that was one of the largest nodes of the times. The "user facing" Internet was deployed years later, globally in the west.
- kragen 5y ago"1987"? The first ARPANET link was active in 01969, and the ARPANET switched from NCP to TCP/IP on January 1, 01983, though the TCP/IP RFCs start in 01976 or 01977. Do you mean it was still deployed as a research network in 01987, as it was in, for example, 01992? Perhaps you meant that 01987 was the last year it was US-only? But vidarh pointed out above that the ARPANET was connected to NORSAR, a research center in Norway, in June 01973, and Norway is in Europe, so in fact our current internet has had some international connections for almost 49 years now.
- peoplefromibiza 5y ago> 1987"? The first ARPANET link was active in 01969, ARPANET is not INTERNET there were many network similar to ARPANET for scope (maybe not size, but Europe was politically much different back then and the wall in Berlin was still there) at the same time ARPANET was alive Russians had their network too since the late 70s, and at one point they connected to the US directly even during the cold war years! (mid 80s). > Perhaps you meant that 01987 was the last year it was US-only? no, it was the year it became "a public accessible network", after NSFNET was established. The year later research centers in Europe were connected to it and were contributing to it. ARPANET was decommissioned in 1990
- vidarh 5y ago> You seem to be arguing against a view that USans invented everything about internetworking No, I was arguing that there is sufficient evidence that the basic internetworking would have been independently invented even if ARPANET had never happened, and that as such, this is also not supported by history: > What I was saying is that the US is where the internet got deployed This is why I said it read like a "history by the victors" view. "The internet" got only got deployed in the US if you take the view that the dozens of other contemporaneous networks at the time did not combine with ARPANET to form the internet, but that ARPANET alone became the internet and replaced the others, or in the strict technical sense that "the Internet" was first used about what sprung out of ARPANET. So, sure, "the" Internet arguably got deployed in the US. But many internets were built in the 1970's. And while ARPANET was early in some respect (e.g. packet switching was first invented at RAND), many of the aspects were also invented or reinvented independently elsewhere, and both academic and commercial deployment of internationally internetworked networks was well developed long before ARPANET connectivity became widely available internationally. As such, an internet would have still existed had ARPANET never happened. It'd have looked different, but not that different. We're left with something ARPANET flavoured because TCP/IP won and existing networks were gradually switched to TCP/IP, not because there weren't alternatives, because there were multiple commercial and public alternatives by the late 70's, predating both TCP/IP and the opening up of access to ARPANET. If you wanted global networking at that time, you'd likely buy access from an X.25 provider, so had ARPANET and/or TCP/IP failed entirely, at worst we'd still have services built on an X.25 descendant (that truly is the worst timeline.... shudder). [Compuserve and Tymnet both used X.25 for at least parts of their networks] Even by the time I started an ISP in '95, not everyone were still convinced TCP/IP was the way forward, and people were still doing things like tunnelling TCP/IP over X.25 because X.25 was still more easily available some places. > I don't think "everything should be a market" is orthogonal to liberalism. At a large enough social scale, liberalism always produces markets unless warfare erupts; strong restrictions on commerce are necessary to prevent markets from arising among groups much larger than Dunbar's number. The point is that the commenter above was not arguing against the existence of markets, but the kind of nickel and diming proposed by Xanadu on expectation of markets for everything. But in terms of writing and knowledge, one of the things the Xanadu people failed to grasp is that the supply far outstrips the demand. For most writing there is no commercial market. In fact, for a whole lot of writing, the commercial value of the writing as a product is negative: people want to pay to push it on others more than people want to pay to read it. Trying to build markets for ideological reasons even where a whole lot of people are desperate for distribution rather than payment is a folly. So I agree with you that liberalism will always produce markets, but I don't think that is relevant to the point. The ideological bent to try to find ways to extract money out of everything is a particular right-libertarian/objectivist subset of liberalist ideologies that most liberalist ideologies do not share.