3 ms·
>Whether you were right or wrong would be both absolute and predetermined. And so pointless to argue about. Doesn't matter. The arguing would happen (or not ha
by coldtea 5y ago
>Whether you were right or wrong would be both absolute and predetermined. And so pointless to argue about.
Doesn't matter. The arguing would happen (or not happen) anyway, because it, too, would be absolute and predetermined.
When people talk about predetermination and lack of free will, they always pause at some point, and talk as if you can have those together with some meta-discussion about them, or an handling (or at least appreciation) of them that's not affected by that predetermination and lack of free will.
I don't blame them for that, of course: they're predetermined to do so. I could have blamed them, of course, but I'm predetermined not to.
- fargle 5y ago> Doesn't matter. The arguing would happen (or not happen) anyway, because it, too, would be absolute and predetermined. Of course! And this would make it a pointless and futile debate then. You might even be right, but you should not win a debate with "it's inevitable and predetermined".
- coldtea 5y ago>Of course! And this would make it a pointless and futile debate then. I'm not so sure about that (but then, I would say so, no matter what). For it to be pointless, something like a "thing having a point" / deeper meaning would have to exist, but none does in a predetermined universe. So, it's not pointless as opposed to pointful, it's in a universe devoid of point-ness altogether. And in a sense it's not futile: in a deterministic cause/effect universe, having that argument is going to affect all future futures. If that argument didn't happen, the universe would still be deterministic (assuming it is to begin with), but the flow of events concerning the people having the argument and anything they affected would have changed.