3 ms·
I'll admit I'm being a bit obtuse, but overall if you're wanting to argue its a safety thing to have knobs then in reality its even more of a safety thing to en
by vel0city 5y ago
I'll admit I'm being a bit obtuse, but overall if you're wanting to argue its a safety thing to have knobs then in reality its even more of a safety thing to encourage the auto controls over having a bunch of buttons and knobs to fiddle with and get distracted by. What's more distracting, taking your hands off the wheel and turning a knob or just having the auto climate control take care of it?
To me, I'd rather not waste large swaths of the dashboard with buttons and knobs I'd never press compared to having it be actually useful like navigation information. Its easier to quickly glance at a map and get useful information from it when the information is bigger than when its smaller.
Literally half of the buttons on the dashboard of one of my car never get pressed. Its wasted space. Meanwhile almost all of the screen on my big screen car gets used every time I drive.
- somebehemoth 5y ago> Meanwhile almost all of the screen on my big screen car gets used every time I drive. Which means your eyes were not on the road every single time you used this interface. Even if you had “wasted space” in your previous analog UI, none of that wasted space took your eyes off the road. The same cannot be said for the vast majority of touch screen user interface interaction. Analog controls are superior for car user interfaces. Touch screens have a use case, but rarely in moving vehicles. I’m not being obtuse. There is no argument that favors touch screen interfaces where human attention is the difference between life and death. Smart cars can have analog inputs. There is no need to choose between one or the other.
- vel0city 5y agoPlease tell me how I'd use a map as an analog control navigated by my hands. I'm supposed to feel the dashboard for the directions, feel around for the layout of the exit bridges I'm approaching? Read the names of the road in braille? As a driver, my hands practically never leave the steering wheel. Media controls happen by the buttons on the steering wheel or voice commands. Climate is automatic. Heated seats are automatic. Heated steering wheel is automatic. The large screen makes it easier to see the directions and layout of the roads I'm approaching. Meanwhile, when I'm not driving my car, the larger screen makes it easier to update the navigation. It makes it easier to plan out the route. It makes it easier for making any fine tuning to the literally hundreds of different settings on my car, settings I really don't need a dedicated button taking up space the 99.9% of the time I'm not pressing the button. Note I'm not a Tesla fanboy, I do think some physical controls are good. Having useful stalks is nice, being able to control things like wipers is still useful as they're not quite 100% yet. However, a thermostat is a solved problem. As a driver, never having to take my hands off the wheel is preferred to physical knobs. And if I never have to take my hands off the wheel, what does it matter if the other controls are physical or not?
- smaudet 5y ago"However, a thermostat is a solved problem." Sure, maybe in a stationary room, and I can think of plenty of times when I have used my heating or cooling system as not a thermostat. Not a sovled problem in cars... I can also think of several scenarios where touch controls are absolutely inadequate, i.e. they simply don't work, the knobs in my car are simple to manipulate, and I do so regularly. Now, do I need 6 buttons to operate all the nonsense in my dash, no - ironically the only "wasted" buttons in my car are the ones related to all the digital touchscreen software I never use... Regarding the GPS - if my phone or dash unit isn't going to read me the right directions, the map unit is useless anyways. The complex stuff I might like the screen for, I need to be paying attention to the road for anyways. That's precisely the wrong time to be learning what the virtual road looks like and ignoring the semi barelling past me on my left as I have three lane changes to make. I guess an argument could be madr for prepping me visually a couple minutes ahead, but auditory feedback is enough. And I don't even need the car for that - I'm usually wearing a headset anyways, just makes for a more seamless auditory experience, I can answer calls, etc. There is really just no reason I want a large visual map display distracting me while I'm driving.
- b112 5y agoAs a driver, never having to take my hands off the wheel is preferred to physical knobs. And if I never have to take my hands off the wheel, what does it matter if the other controls are physical or not? It is normal to often only have one hand on the wheel. Much of Europe loves manual transmissions, and I do too, and it is perfectly, and completely safe. What isn't safe is to be looking away from the road ahead of you. At 80mph, common freeways speeds, it's insane to do so. No current automated controls fix the heat/AC needing to be adjusted, specifically defrosting the windows. Automated wipers suck, and often get it wrong. Mud splashes, must be washed away. Back window fogs, must be addressed. Temps need to be changed, drive modes modified, fog lights turned on, hazard lights engaged to alert traffic around you, on and on and on. All these things can be manipulated with the same hand I use to switch gears, and one hand driving is perfectly safe... I don't care if you never do these things. Most people I speak to, do, and when switching to some cars with screens, end up with constant eyes off road. Throwing automation around is silly. Anyone trying any type of automation experiences edge cases, and often, are simply fighting it. Lastly, based upon the horrid state of current UI design, the last place I want that is in a car.