3 ms·
Thanks for explaining and I understand your point. Regarding others or myself sacrificing: It is necessary in anything, if we are to accomplish much, for many
by wolverine876 5y ago
Thanks for explaining and I understand your point.
Regarding others or myself sacrificing: It is necessary in anything, if we are to accomplish much, for many people to contribute; not much happens alone. So generally no one person can do most of the sacrifice (and I'm not sure it's such a sacrifice), but I definitely believe in doing more than my share.
The other part I think is rooted in common-on-HN perspective on government that I don't happen share. To me, doing it through local government or through organizing neighbors aren't much different. Democracy is another mechanism for how we get together and do things: We take a vote, we agree that we'll go along with the results - sometimes what I like to a greater degree, sometimes to a lesser one, but we also agree that we need to act as a community sometimes and can't be paralyzed, and that others' preferences are just as deserving as mine; and we have the enlightenment and good will and, failing that, the enlightened self-interest, to see that by working together in good faith we can achieve so much more for ourselves.
To me, the idea of compulsion as the basis of democratic government is an interesting philosophical and theoretical question - and answered largely by free elections, representation, free speech, and limited government. Anarchy is similar to me - a philosophical / theoretical question but not reality. They seem to me like some things on HN, in a intellectual atmosphere - a theory taken to the extreme of thinking it's real, or of testing its boundaries by insisting it's real and challenging people to disprove it, rather than something used a tool for exploring reality. Because as a practical matter, I don't see the compulsion: People follow the rules and laws because they want to; we are social beings, even evolved to live socially and emotionally fall apart if alone. I pay my taxes, follow most laws because I would anyway (e.g., I don't want to murder or steal), and others because I want to do my part for my neighbors; I respect my neighbors votes. Compulsion isn't the basis, it's just a band-aid solution we sometimes use; there aren't nearly enough resources to make everyone obey if they don't want to.
You seem to think differently, which is fine, but I think it's factually wrong to assume that everyone - who almost all live in democracies - agrees. Also, I think the compulsion theory is yet another attempt by certain groups (not you) to attack our democracy, to politicize the very idea of it, by transforming it from an achievement of humanity and a way we can live with hope and progress, to something dark and pernicious.
- WalterBright 5y agoI see again the idea that for people to cooperate, compulsion must be used. I don't agree with this at all, and the US is full of effective and efficient cooperation without compulsion. These can involve literally tens of thousands of people, all voluntarily cooperating towards a common goal. I also propose to you that voting is not the same thing at all as having a choice. For example, every election in my state has tax increases on the ballot. They always pass. What happened to my choice? I have to pay the increased taxes, whether I voted or not, whether I voted yea or nay, whether I want to or not. > People follow the rules and laws because they want to By and large in the US, they do. But they are still compelled to. Every law lists the penalties for non-compliance. A democracy is far better than a dictatorship, but I'm not under any delusions that the will of the majority is not backed up by compulsion. To put it more simply, a democracy is two wolves and a sheep voting on what's for dinner (that's why we have a Bill of Rights, btw).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wolverine876 5y ago> I also propose to you that voting is not the same thing at all as having a choice. For example, every election in my state has tax increases on the ballot. They always pass. What happened to my choice? I have to pay the increased taxes, whether I voted or not, whether I voted yea or nay, whether I want to or not. You have a choice and other people in your state have equal choices (maybe me!), and of course not 100% will agree, and so democracy respects all those choices. Democracy, in a sense, is a respect for other people's opinions and choices. I'm not pretending there is no compulsion at all, or that sometimes things that could be or should be voluntary are made universal through law. And then so few inform themselves, and there is so much mis- and disinformation, and so few vote. So yeah, it's a mess. It's a messy human system, and so is every other system: As I think you are a veteran of IT systems, I'm sure you know that even our logic machines are fundamentally messy and human. But volunteering, which I've done plenty of, isn't so ideal either. Some things I do voluntarily are necessary and should be universal, and my neighbors sit home and leave the work to me. (I'm not crying, just observing dynamics of it.) Some parties make the 'voluntary' compulsory through very undemocratic pressure, and a democratic system would be better. Volunteer structures often omit the input of people who are affected by the situation but lack time, money, status, etc. - people who would have a say if done democratically. Sometimes that's done intentionally, so powerful parties can run over the vulnerable. 'Voluntary' can mean 'extra-legal'. Some parties 'volunteer' for their own good to avoid meeting obligations to the group - e.g., wealthy parties fund 'business district' quasi-governmental services and then rage when asked to contribute to the collective good, like schools or cleaning other neighborhoods. In some places, wealthy parties directly fund police equipment - it's not a compulsory tax, but probably a very bad idea. In an Apple Store in one city I noticed a uniformed city police officer acting like a security guard; I inquiried politely and they said Apple paid the city directly for their services. Democracy has a lot of built-in equity. My main point is that democratic government is one way (not the only way) we voluntarily (though not always voluntarily) organize ourselves. Self-government is another term used for democracy - how could we manage without a king or some superior governing us and compelling us? It turns out, we could get together and cooperate, and function better than a king - a pretty optimistic development after 10,000 years of civilization. Democratic government is not some pernicious special case, compelling us under its yoke, though like any tool it has advantages and disadvantages we should consider (including the compulsory parts). > To put it more simply, a democracy is two wolves and a sheep voting on what's for dinner (that's why we have a Bill of Rights, btw). That is one of my favorite ways to express what I think is a fundamental concept about human rights and mob rule, and so I agree completely. > I see again the idea that for people to cooperate, compulsion must be used. I wrote also about volunteerism.