3 ms·
The last bullet point is something folks on both sides of the aisle should appreciate: > Thus, we ought to be skeptical of social scientists’ ability to reliab
by rayiner 5y ago
The last bullet point is something folks on both sides of the aisle should appreciate:
> Thus, we ought to be skeptical of social scientists’ ability to reliably inform public policy, and of policymakers’ ability to evaluate social-scientific research objectively, particularly when it is “policy relevant.”
Think of how much we’re debating what’s causing the current inflation we’re seeing. That’s one number in a field that’s quite amenable to quantitative analysis. I think we have pretty much zero credible scientific evidence to justify most policies involving public welfare. There’s a handful of exceptions—e.g. the tremendous work done studying the benefits of the clean air act, for example. But that was rigorous research done by the EPA over literally decades.
I think we should give poor families with kids money because that seems like the morally correct thing to do. But this sort of thing is just scientism: https://calteches.library.caltech.edu/51/2/CargoCult.htm https://calteches.library.caltech.edu/51/2/CargoCult.htm
- xyzzyz 5y agoEven the air pollution literature is most likely biased: the negative effects are real, but the studies are exaggerating them. For one thing, Andrew Gelman thinks that the effects of air pollution are overestimated, and it's the one guy I'd trust when it comes to assessing quality of scientific evidence. https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2022/04/02/why-the-new-pollution-literature-is-credible-but-im-still-guessing-that-the-effects-are-being-overestimated/ https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2022/04/02/why-the-ne...
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoHe does use the word 'guess' for his belief and makes no attempt to put any kind of error bars, confidence interval or lower bounds on that, which seems a bit rhetorically weak. He also suggests that he broadly agrees with the post he links to and that it gets a lot of ideologically motivated political pushback so this seems like the Ying to his Yang, an example of politically motivated disregard for solid science just going in the opposite direction.
- xyzzyz 5y agoHis point is not that it’s a solid science, but rather that the hypothesis they are studying is actually true, which helps with not being hopelessly wrong.