7 ms·
Please keep in mind this is a rewards program text box, not a chat app. The program itself may be stupid, but I don't know any company that would allow these t
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
Please keep in mind this is a rewards program text box, not a chat app.
The program itself may be stupid, but I don't know any company that would allow these terms in internally visible recognition.
My company uses manual review for recognition, but I would expect a call from my manager if I sent a public kudos "Great job fighting for union pay raises for the slave labor at our company"
- mellosouls 5y agoI don't know any company that would allow these terms in an internally visible recognition. Certainly not the case at every organisation; unions have a strong presence in some long-established private industries and public sector organisations, including general communications.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoDo those companies have recognition programs where where you can reward people for union topics?
- mellosouls 5y agoThat's very different to the quote which claimed no supported visible presence.
- lupire 5y agoThat's why it is illegal for management to interfere with labor organizing. Because they will abuse their power wherever they can.
- tyingq 5y ago"union" would be a pretty normal term for a kudos app. Like "great job working with the union and the company on that safety issue!"
- marricks 5y agoThe article referred to it as an "internal social media program." Why call it something else? Do you know more about its functionality you wish to share with the rest of us?
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThis is a fair question. My process was to read the article and pull out the factual quotes, and ignore the title, innuendo, and dog whistles. >In November 2021, Amazon convened a high-level meeting in which top executives discussed plans to create an internal social media program that would let employees recognize co-workers’ performance with posts called “Shout-Outs,” >Shout-Outs would be part of a gamified rewards system in which employees are awarded virtual stars and badges for activities that “add direct business value,” documents state. >“With free text, we risk people writing Shout-Outs that generate negative sentiments among the viewers and the receivers,” a document summarizing the program states. “We want to lean towards being restrictive on the content that can be posted to prevent a negative associate experience.” To me this sounds exactly like the directed recognition at many tech companies and those I have used. You dump a thank you in a text box, and someone gets a notification their manager can see. It is not a place to talk about your kids, dog, or weekend plans. It is not a place to submit "constructive feedback" on your peers or company.
- rsanek 5y agoHow about other banned terms like accessibility, unite/unity, restrooms, fairness, diversity? Do those also feel unreasonable for any company to include in an internal app? To me, these terms are only concerning because it's Amazon. The people behind the project are self-aware enough to realize these are such big issues that people will talk about them, but I guess they'd rather prevent discussion altogether than deal with the actual problems.
- panarky 5y ago
- tomschlick 5y agoNot the parent commenter, but its pretty weird / creepy that you spent the time to go through 2 years of their posts to find that rather innocuous comment. Also, it isn't really cancel culture for a company to say they dont want that on their internal kudos app presumably while using company equipment.
- zaik 5y agoIt only takes a few seconds to find a keyword in someones comment history: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=s1artibartfast%20cancel%20culture&sort=byDate&type=all https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- MathCodeLove 5y agoWhy would they search specifically for "cancel culture"? It seems pretty obvious that the individual didn't search but instead took the time to try and find anything they could to make OP look bad.
- cheeze 5y agoI agree it's super weird, doesn't feel in the spirit of HN to me.
- zorpner 5y agoBecause it was immediately obvious from their post that they are engaged in political posturing rather than legitimate debate? It's really not hard to tell.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIt is a politically loaded article about a politically loaded topic. Of course any factual commentary will have political implications. Humans have bias, I have bias, and so does everyone posting in this thread. That doesn't negate the point I raised
- geysersam 5y agoHonestly banning words just seems incompetent. It's horrible PR. Will the achived effect be worth it? I doubt that.
- kqr 5y agoWhile the whole idea of gameified communication is ridiculous, I really don't get your point. If someone feels so strongly about the issue that they want to send someone a kudos using the specifi words "union pay raises for slave labour", that's definitely something I'd want to encourage as much as possible of, because it is a strong indication I'm doing something wrong as a leader. You have to admit people won't use those words for fun in a professional environment. Those messages would be one of the most important signals uncovered by such a program. I just don't get why you'd want to bury it. ---- Though reading my own comment, it's clearly selection bias: leaders who encourage workers' open discussion of slave-like conditions would never institute slave-like conditions, and vice versa, I suppose.
- zardo 5y ago"Good job taking out the trash from the restroom when the janitorial staff was out getting the vaccine!" "Good job taking out the *** from the ****** when the janitorial staff was out getting the ******!"