2 ms·
Modified comparative fault seems to make the most sense to me (it was actually the one I was thinking about when I said contributory negligence, refering to the
by giantg2 5y ago
Modified comparative fault seems to make the most sense to me (it was actually the one I was thinking about when I said contributory negligence, refering to the action and not the rule).
The only real issue I have with the pure method is that theoretically a lower bar to bring a suit might encourage more to be brought and can lead to some perverse outcomes like the Ralph's case.
I mean, I don't have a lot of faith in the justice system based off of things I've personally seen in it. But even just taking the Ralph's example (which admittedly I should look into more), the impact of the truck being parked there seems like it should be essentially nonexistent. He was going to hit something, hard. The only real question was how much did the truck being parked there contribute to the outcome as opposed to hitting some other object. Without any real details, it seems that the outcome would have happened anyways, especially if he was simultaneously suffering from some medical condition.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> But even just taking the Ralph's example (which admittedly I should look into more), the impact of the truck being parked there seems like it should be essentially nonexistent. Reserving any judgement on whether this is true or not, if it was, that's a problem with the jury determination of fault, not with comparative negligence, per se. By avoiding sharp cutoffs, pure comparative negligence minimizes the risk of truly perverse results due to jury misassignment of fault. (Pure contributory negligence is the absolute worst for this, where finding something that had no contribution on the part of the person who suffered damage had even minimal contribution eliminates all recovery.) > He was going to hit something, hard. Maybe; I mean there are lots of ways a speeding vehicle with an intoxicated or otherwise medically incapacitated driver that has gone well onto the shoulder of an interstate can end up coming to a stop, and not all of them involve hitting something hard (though most of them aren't good, to be sure.)
- giantg2 5y agoI guess what I'm saying is that if someone can get half a million dollars from running off the road and hitting someone else who was at minimal fault (10%), then what's the point of any activity that exposes you to risk? Even with insurance, you end up paying a bunch of money. No point in starting a business if a driver can screw up after not obeying you and you still get sued. "By avoiding sharp cutoffs, pure comparative negligence minimizes the risk of truly perverse results due to jury misassignment of fault" It seems this is only true near the cutoff, and not near the margins. Just to continue on the possibility that this 10% determination was a jury mistake, that a half million dollar mistake. I'd hardly call that minimal. This case is far from the cutoffs of other states. This seems to also support my idea that the modified approach would reduce litigation, which I see as a benefit.