3 ms·
What Happens When We Die? (Bullshit?)
- cydonian_monk 15y agoUnfortunately, the only way anyone can know for sure is to die. The scientist and engineer in me says "nothing" happens, that you won't know you're dead because consciousness stops and is never recovered. That these "paranormal" cases are creations of a machine that can't accept the nothingness of its demise. That a belief in life after death is also a construction to allow us to die with dignity and without fear. That "Near-Death" experiences are the result of the memory-recording portion of our brain continuing while the brain stem and other parts have failed. Still, a part of me says no. No way. That something continues. This other part of me wants to believe. It reminds me that I've experienced things that can't be explained by the above science. As have countless others. If there really is a part of "us" separate from the brain, as suggested by this article, then our "soul," if you will, must live in the "cloud" with our brain operating as some sort of radio. I've not seen hard physical evidence of anything of the sort. (But if it's true, God help us if we learn the API.) Near-Death Experiences are a curious subject, and one that deserves real examination. Ages ago (in high school), I attempted to base a research paper on NDEs. Finding sources from medical research was impossible, as there weren't any. The subject was strictly reserved to "New Age Mysticism," and ignored by practitioners for reasons of career self preservation. Not much seems to have changed.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Symbol 15y agoWhat's with the color comment in the title? The article does not attempt to prove or refute a thesis, but merely explain the premise of a book. Why call "bullshit" on that? It's slightly inflammatory for no real good reason. I have no vested interest in the subject matter, so maybe that makes a difference, but I dont want to see HN turn into Fark.
- smoyer 15y agoI'm not sure I understand the purpose of the expletive in the title. This seems to be a doctor that is intent on finding the answer using the scientific method. Why provide a commentary until he reports his results? What happens he he proves part of us lives in a spirit realm? What happens if science somehow proves there's a God? I think this is very much like the current brouhaha over the faster-than-light particles at the LHC ... Either there's an error in the experiment or we don't understand physics the way we thought we did ... And either there's a scientific explanation for NDE or there's a facet to our consciousness we don't understand. But either way, let's continue the studies!
- vstm 15y agoI think we shouldn't interpret things into this article which simply aren't there. His main point is obviously "death is not a moment" that means the chemical processes in your body don't stop the moment the doctor says "He's dead Jim". I haven't thought about this so this is an interesting point. So the question is what processes are still up&running in our brain during that time? I had hoped for a little bit more enlightenment from the article in that matter.