3 ms·
Were the Victorians really a classist society, though? If anything, they probably were the first 'mass' society where a basic worldview and perspective wrt. sta
by zozbot234 5y ago
Were the Victorians really a classist society, though? If anything, they probably were the first 'mass' society where a basic worldview and perspective wrt. standards of moral and ethical behavior was shared irrespective of social strata, which would make them a rather "classless" society at least in a Marxist-influenced sense. Modern societies are certainly very different - morality and virtue tend to be regarded there as an explicitly upper class concern, and to be viewed elsewhere as mere tiresome "virtue signaling" of some kind or another.
- pram 5y agoCalling Victorian England classless in a “Marxist” sense is pretty rich, considering Engels impressions of their working class pretty much led to the development of Communism.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI mean, have you seen Downton Abbey? (Not Victorian I know, but if anything the show highlights how morals are changing from the Victorian ideals of the past). I know it's a fictional show, but the fact that one's lot it life is largely a result of who your parents are (and to a lesser degree who you marry) would certainly point to it being a "classist" society, even if all of the classes generally agree on this hereditary status.
- simulate-me 5y agoIt’s disturbing that historical fiction, especially television, is so often used as evidence of some type of historical precedent. Regardless of the subject’s accuracy, television shows are ultimately written to evoke an emotional response which can’t help but color the viewers perception of the historical events. For instance, in Downton Abbey, part of the drama involves the relationship between the staff and the nobility. The focus on this specific type of relationship may make the viewer believe it was more or less prominent than in reality.
- ashtonkem 5y agoYou see a similar thing with fantasy television being interpreted as evidence towards non-fantastical elements of medieval life, when they really represent our modern feelings towards the past more than anything else.
- 8note 5y agoIf you want an alternative example, the same argument applies to India's caste system. If people agree that the caste system is correct, is it still classist? I'd say yes, because it enforces the maintenance of classes, and assigns people different opportunities based on their class. The substance of the opinions matter more than the consensus
- zozbot234 5y agoBut the caste system was explicitly based on the idea that people in different "castes" cannot possibly relate to one another. By contrast, one of the most recurrent themes in Victorian-age fiction is the trope that even "low-class" people can oftentimes embody supposedly-'elite' moral values and standards of behavior a lot better than actual members of the elite do. Thus essentially flipping the whole idea of virtue signaling on its head.
- ungamedplayer 5y ago> is so often used as evidence of some type of historical precedent. Wait till you see Bridgerton. Ive had a teenage girl mentionthe series of an example of "how things were".
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoThe sad/bizarre thing is that I've seen a number of serious articles/commentery that Queen Charlotte was actually black or biracial, which is basically invented nonsense. Even if you give too much credence to a piece of her ancestry 15 generations back, given all the intermarriage of European royalty, most of Europe's royals have Madragana as an ancestor, including King George III. I think this is especially sad because there are much more fascinating true stories of European nobility with Sub-Saharan ancestry, e.g. the famous Russian poet Alexander Pushkin's great grandfather, Abram Petrovich Gannibal, was black.
- robotresearcher 5y agoGeorge Orwell’s ‘The Road to Wigan Pier’ is an argument for socialism in the social context of the time, and presents an intensely classist society, published 36 years after Victoria died. It’s a very interesting book: a snapshot of how people lived, whose lives were rarely portrayed in literature.
- kergonath 5y agoNot to mention “Down and out in Paris and London”. Again, as you say, intensely classist.
- logicchains 5y ago> morality and virtue tend to be regarded there as an explicitly upper class concern, and to be viewed elsewhere as mere tiresome "virtue signaling" of some kind or another. This is a very unfair comparison. The working class regard a certain kind of white leftism, one completely removed from the actual concerns of the working class, as "virtue signalling". It's extremely arrogant to assume one's own views constitute the entirely of "morality and virtue"; different people have different morals.
- goodpoint 5y ago> Were the Victorians really a classist society, though? Yes, and it was one of the most classist societies that existed. https://www.britannica.com/event/Victorian-era https://www.britannica.com/event/Victorian-era