3 ms·
> I did a full factory reset, signed in to his account again, and now the system is once again locked down. That’s by design though isn’t it? You logged in wi
by duxup 5y ago
> I did a full factory reset, signed in to his account again, and now the system is once again locked down.
That’s by design though isn’t it? You logged in with a managed account and the policy was applied again?
The account is his school account right?
That’s pretty much how Chrome OS works.
This might just be a good lesson that you want to maintain device / role boundaries.
- trasz 5y agoA gaping security hole is fine if it’s been introduced on purpose?
- duxup 5y ago> A gaping security hole What is that?
- trasz 5y ago“the system installed GoGuardian monitoring software on the Chromebook without notice or permission.”
- micromacrofoot 5y agoIt's tied directly to the remotely managed account, that's how the account works. If you don't sign into the account, the software won't be installed. Students don't get to decide what software to install when it comes to logging in to school accounts. Generally the laptops are provided by the district, but it seems OP was trying to add another personal device to their system. You can't participate in their system without the software. So I guess the alternative would be to block personal devices from logging in like this at all.
- duxup 5y agoWhen I logged in with my son’s school account on chrome OS it had some notifications about who owns the account and so on. I don’t think it is as much a mystery as implied. In the end there’s no getting around that mixing device uses like this doesn’t work. It works less and less as the history of computers goes on.
- xg15 5y agoCan the managed account actually access files from the unmanaged account or control which processes are active while the unmanaged account runs? Because, if yes, this absolutely does sound like a security hole: 1) Set up an organisation and add a managed account. Set up policies that install a backdoor on first login. 2) Get hold of victim's Chromebook. 3) Log into the Chromebook using the account from (1) 4) Chromebook will execute the policies and run the backdoor. 5) Use the backdoor to snoop victim's files. You've successfully gained access to the victim's files without knowing their password. Profit! This would work even if the victim is fully aware of the issue and never intended to mix managed and unmanaged accounts on their own.
- ghostpepper 5y agoDoes a chromebook allow you to have more than one user account? It sounds like a factory reset was necessary to allow enrollment
- MereInterest 5y agoChromebooks do allow more than one user account, yes. The factory reset mentioned by the OP was necessary in order to undo the enrollment, as no application of Administrator/Owner privileges would undo it otherwise.
- ac29 5y agoI think you misunderstand the original post - the parent didnt have some sort of local administrator account (which isnt really a thing on ChromeOS). They signed into a managed account run by the school district, didnt like the policy, then reset the device, signed into the same managed account again, and noticed the same policy was applied.
- toast0 5y ago> local administrator account (which isnt really a thing on ChromeOS). The first user to sign in on a chromebook has limited special powers. I don't think they involve reading other people's data though.
- MereInterest 5y ago> That’s pretty much how Chrome OS works. And that's the problem. Signing onto a remote account is a request to access a remote resource, and should not be interpreted as granted the remote actor control over local resources. That Chrome OS works this way implies that Chrome OS is fundamentally flawed.
- duxup 5y agoMaybe there should be more of a notice, but when I tried it with my son’s account I got some notifications. Having said all that the default will be for most school accounts… all or nothing. Don’t allow them to manage it and you won’t get in.
- gime_tree_fiddy 5y agoCan't speak for OP, but generally this is mentioned during the sign in process, so it should be laid out. It is effectively all or nothing.
- MereInterest 5y agoMy issue isn't about the notification, but that this doesn't work at all within any reasonable model of user permissions. Fundamentally, authority cannot be delegated authority that you yourself don't have. I can agree to a contract promising to do some particular work, because I have the authority to direct my actions. I cannot agree to a contract promising that you will do some particular work, because you haven't granted me that authority. I cannot grant to another what I do not have for myself. With regards to user permissions, a non-administrator doesn't have permission to monitor another user's activity. Therefore, they cannot delegate permission to a third party to monitor another user's activity. That this is possible means that ChromeOS has a fundamentally flawed model of user permissions.
- cyral 5y agoWindows does this as well, and I would expect other management solutions to as well. You can build your own PC and be local admin on it, but the second you sign in to an active directory account (using a VPN for work) that account will be locked down and can run scripts that the AD owner chooses. I imagine that is what is happening here as well, where the user has signed into the school Google Workspace account (or whatever it's called these days). To avoid this, they could sign in to Google Docs and Google Classroom in a browser. (Although to be fair, Chrome does aggressively ask if you want to sign into Chrome with your account, and probably if you want to sign into the user profile on ChromeOS if I had to guess)
- shapefrog 5y ago> This might just be a good lesson that you want to maintain device / role boundaries. This is the teachable moment here. Better for the poster and their child to learn it now rather than in the workplace. It doesnt make it right, but the 90's and 00's with work browsing and email full of porn, dickpics and assorted filth were not right either.