4 ms·
I'd argue that anyone who's trying to dictate what you are and aren't allowed to install on a device you bought with your own money is the scammer in that situa
by smoldesu 5y ago
I'd argue that anyone who's trying to dictate what you are and aren't allowed to install on a device you bought with your own money is the scammer in that situation. If Apple thinks those aforementioned parties are running predatory pricing schemes, then they're welcome to take any number of actions to discourage people from using those apps; the App Store could show a big orange "lootbox" banner at the top of each offending app, show a modal when you subscribe to an app that warns you about recurring payments, or create an individual review section for the value-add of any IAPs.
But that's not why they removed any of those apps. They kicked them to the curb because their developers thought paying a 30% tax for a payment processor they didn't need was silly, and Apple refused to serve their content unless they kowtowed to their rent collection. You're either misremembering things or creating justifications that don't align with the reality of the situation. Apple is trying to play the side of the public distributor of software and the private denier of apps at the same time. These attempts to keep the Cathedral and the Bazaar under one roof rarely work out though, and I don't really know what they're expecting if they think that our government is just going to turn a blind eye to a distribution monopoly like that, especially if Apple continues to charge developers for it.
- tempnow987 5y agoApple throws a LOT of weight around that users would NEVER be able to force. They've forced no tracking. No individual user could EVER hope to achieve that. Facebook et al track everywhere else. This made the big player mad. Here comes DOJ to crack down on this "abuse". They force easy subscription cancellations, and remind users on app delete to cancel subs. They control app refunds on scam apps (I've had this once, refund was quick). They are forcing apps to allow for truly private signups (apple ID based). Apple's business model is to create a walled garden that appeals to users tired of the DOJ's and FTC failed efforts on the internet at large. Yes, they charge rent ON THE BUSINESSES that want to play in this garden. Because of the high user trust user spend in this garden is HUGE compared to other platforms. DOJ / FTC could take action on anything online where rampant scams (tech support) and frauds go totally unchecked. No action by DOJ/FTC. Seriously, your grandma will get bogus tech support help, they will loot her account, and you will not even get a call back. Tellingly, DOJ/FTC focus on Apple, a company with FAR higher customer approval than almost any of there folks DOJ is carrying water for (scam shopping comparison sites, scam recurring memberships / subscriptions etc). The idea that apple are "scammers" goes to show how warped the values are of the folks on the internet at large, including developers who consistently enable the many dark patterns. My elderly parents WILL NOT buy anything non apple. When they have a problem with their device, they get legit support (not always free) from apple. Meanwhile, the list of crap behavior by every OTHER player online is crazy, from the "free" email providers (who spam and scam their way with toolbars and add-ins) to all the rest. Seriously, if they were to actually trust DOJ/FTC to keep the net clean, and signed up for another free online service (with the required toolbars etc) they'd be in for another round of crazy pop-ups and pain.
- candiddevmike 5y agoApple has search ads on the app store that can target demographic information about their users. Where do you think Apple sources that information from? It's the same crap Google does where they collect data but don't share it with other companies. The only difference is Apple hides their probably-anti-trust-worthy user tracking shenanigans behind feel good user measures that block the same tracking for competitors.
- tempnow987 5y agoI don't use apple app store ads, this is a relatively tiny exposure in the Apple ecosystem. I just compare this to for example buying the FTC and DOJ approved Vizio TV, which will both monitor what you watch, sell that to third parties, and start popping up ads on the device you bought. Yes, a clickthrough policy gives them the OK to do this, but my trust in them and FTC/DOJ is low. Apple ads as far as I can tell does not do the data broker buy / sell, and you can usually turn this stuff off / on here: Settings > Privacy > Apple Advertising If you want you can easily see the segments you fall into. I know you claim this is the same thing Facebook provides. I doubt it personally.
- candiddevmike 5y agoLet's see what side of the argument Apple lands on when real user data protections are enacted with stiff penalties. Otherwise their entire schtick is "do as I say not as I do". They have the money and political connections to push real change through, they just profit too much by being the sole data broker on iOS (see Google paying them for preferential treatment).
- tempnow987 5y agoSure. This is an easy prediction. Because they actually CHARGE for their services, including a 30% cut of sales on app store, they don't need to sell you out. So data protection is much less a threat to them then it is to google / facebook et al. The weird thing is folks on HN have a hard-on for destroying Apple, when we know that if regulators ACTUALLY cracked down on a real abuse (Vizio selling your viewing) Apple would be unphased (they probably don't sell any data to third parties) as their ad revenue is a fraction of their overall massive revenue from actual sales.