2 ms·
> There is some kind of crazy joint and severable liability which means if city is even like 5% at fault, if no one else can pay the $10M, they might have too?
by tzs 5y ago
> There is some kind of crazy joint and severable liability which means if city is even like 5% at fault, if no one else can pay the $10M, they might have too?
Joint and several liability isn't crazy when you realize that by the time a civil case gets to court it is often the case that some party must get screwed.
Suppose X and Y are both at fault in something that caused serious injury to Z. Z was not at all at fault. Further suppose that X is 90% at fault and Y is 10% at fault, and that a just damages award to Z would be $1 million.
The most just outcome would be that X pays $900000 to Z and Y pays $100000 to Z.
But that only actually works if X can pay $900000 and Y can pay $100000. Suppose either X or Y is cannot pay, or maybe can eventually pay put it is going to take a lot of time and effort to squeeze the money out of them.
Then either Z gets screwed by not getting their full damages paid or by having to spend a lot of time and effort collecting them, or whichever one of X and Y that has money gets screwed by having to pay more than their fair share upfront.
With joint and several liability the idea is that if we have to screw someone, which we do in this situation, it is better to screw someone who was actually at fault than to screw someone who was not at fault.
A party that ends up getting screwed by having to pay more than their fair share can then sue the other at fault parties for the overpayment. So if say it would be hard for Z to collect $900000 from X they can get it from Y, and then it is Y's problem to figure out how to squeeze $900000 from X.