2 ms·
I'm a little torn on this. On the one hand, this is really impressive for on-the-fly photogrammetry. On the other hand though, this asset kinda just looks... ba
by smoldesu 5y ago
I'm a little torn on this. On the one hand, this is really impressive for on-the-fly photogrammetry. On the other hand though, this asset kinda just looks... bad? From a distance it's pretty passable, and in a relative vacuum of visual information it looks fine. However, the material itself is really sketchy. Whatever their default shader settings are makes the leather look toy-ish, caught somewhere between a reflective and diffuse material. The texturing is pretty low-quality (as expected), but the really annoying part is how it handles the ambient occlusion on the surface: it just looks like self-shadowing is baked into the texture.
It's a cool proof-of-concept, but I'm not quite sure who could use it in it's current state. Even by video game standards, these assets would probably look really out-of-place...
- mkaic 5y agoAs a 3D artist who uses a lot of photoscans -- the scan quality looks fantastic to me! Photoscanned assets aren't usually meant to hold up up close, they're more intended for quickly building out a larger scene. Additionally, the material you see straight out of the app can be enhanced significantly with some common shader tricks like faking a bump/roughness map. Lastly, good lighting makes a world of difference when using photoscanned assets. Personally, I've just joined the beta and expect I'll be taking advantage of it heavily for several upcoming CGI projects.
- smoldesu 5y agoAll good! I'm not trying to detract from anyone's enjoyment/use of the product if they have one :p I'm just a 3D hobbyist, and I don't really do a lot of photo scans. My thoughts on the matter are coming purely from a CG/asset generation perspective, if you're an artist with a little more agency with how you represent 3D objects then I bet you could work wonders with this (especially the geometry portion). Perhaps it was silly for me to expect these scans to rival hand-made assets, but my larger point was that we simply have a long ways to go before we reach parity with the two. In the time that's passed, I actually did come up with a use for it though. It might be fun to use Blender's layer functionality to "trace" a 3D scan into a higher-res production model, just to get proportions right. I'll probably still hold off until this reaches general availability though.
- hunterb123 5y agoI'd assume the model itself is the important part, the texture guessing is nice, but you'd probably want to apply your own PBR texture.
- andybak 5y agoIn my experience both go hand in hand. 3D scanned meshes aren't particularly detailed and texturing them is far from simple.
- axg11 5y agoThis looks bad to you? Admittedly I have little experience with 3D models. As a layperson this model looks incredible to me. If the real life results are anything close to that then photogrammetry is as good as solved, as far as my eyes are concerned.
- smoldesu 5y agoWell, that's why I say I'm torn. I really do think this is cool, but when you compare it to hand-made assets the two would look starkly different. My biggest gripe is with the lighting: if you look at the creases of the couch, you can see that the lighting is literally "baked" in to the model. Shadows are rendered by the texture instead of the lighting engine, which means the models will appear static if you use them in a dynamically lit environment. Worse yet is the fact that these "shadows" can actually reflect light since the model has no reflection mapping or light mapping to tell the renderer that the shadows are rough as opposed to glossy. That gives the model the aforementioned "toy look" that I brought up earlier. It's still quite cool, but asset capture has a long ways to go (even if everyone's results are this good).