3 ms·
> if they'll listen This is where I find the line easier to draw. Starting from a wrong premise and reaching a wrong conclusion (even if reached rationally and
by Jtsummers 5y ago
> if they'll listen
This is where I find the line easier to draw. Starting from a wrong premise and reaching a wrong conclusion (even if reached rationally and logically) does not, itself, make a crackpot. The crackpot is the one who won't listen to the counterarguments. And when they do listen, they just shift the goalposts instead of actually adjusting their basis to better fit reality.
- epgui 5y agoAgreed. A looser, less perfect, but more easily applicable and economical heuristic that I have is: - Is my (layperson) interlocutor mostly contrarian and skeptical of others? Then there is very little chance that trying to point them in the right direction will be productive. Being a reasonable contrarian requires a very high level of expertise. - Is my interlocutor mostly curious and skeptical of their own understanding? Then my friend, this person is a rare golden perl, and I will spare no effort or patience, because in almost every case these people are the ones who haven’t lost the capacity to learn.