9 ms·
Morality is sticky here. I personally believe in universal health care and would say that his medical expenses SHOULD be covered without any sort of legal invo
by cogman10 5y ago
Morality is sticky here.
I personally believe in universal health care and would say that his medical expenses SHOULD be covered without any sort of legal involvement. Hell, dude going around high and drunk probably needs to be in an addiction recovery program as well.
The reason he's suing is because he can't afford his medical bills and the legal bills end up compounding the problem. Were there no medical bills, the lawsuit he could bring up would pretty much be pain and suffering... maybe.
So, should taxpayers be on the hook? Partially in the sense that I think all medical problems should be publicly funded. Morally, removing discretion around who gets medical treatment and treating everyone ends up being a good. Will you waste money on people doing dumb things? Sure. However, you won't waste money having a giant system of people trying to weasel their way out of every payment (insurance). More people get their healthcare needs taken care of. An absolute net good.
- giantg2 5y agoThe interesting thing is how we might adjust as a society with something like universal healthcare. In theory, it's possible the accident might not have happened at all if we decided as a society that e-scooters, alcohol, and weed, were all things that lead to expensive care, and we highly restricted them to help control health system costs. Although it also depends on how that universal system works. For example, some systems require people with "preventable" conditions to pay an extra tax for their services.
- cogman10 5y ago> if we decided as a society that e-scooters, alcohol, and weed, were all things that lead to expensive care, and we highly restricted them to help control health system costs. Perhaps e-scooters could be restricted. However, intoxicating substances are pretty much impossible to stop (We've tried). The problem is that most intoxicant substances can be made anywhere with a very low amount of equipment. So, rather than focusing on restricting access, IMO, the better route is focusing on supporting behavior/lifestyle changes. Though, if we are talking about fixing costs, then one thing that'd help tremendously would public access exercise facilities. It's a lot cheaper to operate a gym than a hospital.
- giantg2 5y ago"Though, if we are talking about fixing costs, then one thing that'd help tremendously would public access exercise facilities." I kind of doubt a lack of facility is the blocker. There's nothing stopping people from doing body weight exercises in their home. "However, intoxicating substances are pretty much impossible to stop" True, we would only want to restrict it, not stop it. Basically, make the bar for the legal stuff higher enough to persuade people not to use it, but also set it lower than the illegal stuff. Of course it also needs to be accompanied with the lifestyle changes. Just look at tobacco - legal, heavily taxed, providing minors is heavily punished, large warnings required, even requiring manufacturers to pay for commercials to smear their own product. This could be applied to just about anything.
- cogman10 5y ago> Just look at tobacco - legal, heavily taxed, providing minors is heavily punished, large warnings required, even requiring manufacturers to pay for commercials to smear their own product. This could be applied to just about anything. I could definitely see getting more on board with that. Seems like such campaigns have been somewhat successful in multiple regions. The main thing I'm against is the criminalization of consumption, that's a fools errand. More good education early on is a lot better than what I grew up with. The DARE program was such a joke.
- giantg2 5y ago"The DARE program was such a joke." It was so long ago, but I though it was very detailed and informative. I think it's enough to keep curious kids uninterested in using. No amount of education will keep the hopeless person from using. And I mean hopeless as in they lack hope for their life and feel its over already, then they choose to use anyways knowing about the effects.