3 ms·
Rome had a huge empire and could therefore field large armies so yes they had a real logistical advantage. As to feudal soldiers vs legionnaires it was largely
by Retric 5y ago
Rome had a huge empire and could therefore field large armies so yes they had a real logistical advantage.
As to feudal soldiers vs legionnaires it was largely a question of equipment. Mounted knights required horse that weren’t available to Rome because selective breeding had yet to produce them. Improvements in metalwork and armor design resulted in far better coverage for the same weight. Knights largely stopped using shields because they didn’t need them as much as they could use a free hand.
That said there was a large variation on both sides. Disease, exhaustion etc could also wreck an otherwise capable army.
- pasabagi 5y ago>Rome had a huge empire and could therefore field large armies My feeling is actually that as the empire grew, the armies they could field somewhat declined. When Cannae happened, the Romans were big, but not huge, and they could literally field army after army of professional soldiers. Part of this was demographics (there had been a population boom in Italy) but part of it is economics and state capacity. I would guess that up until really late (like, 1880's) warfare was not that technical, so stuff like 'elan' and 'will' was typically by far the most important characteristic in a soldier. That's at least what generals right up to the first world war tended to prize. When it comes to sheer discipline, bloodymindedness and martial spirit, I don't think anybody would surpass the Romans until the modern era.